I'm not a classical aficionado and therefore, lack your refined sensitivity and discernment when it comes to comparing different versions of a particular piece. I will say that, personally, I find the Pires recording of the Nocturnes quite emotionally affecting. I bought it after listening to perhaps a half dozen pianists' interpretations of the Nocturnes on Spotify. However, this was some time ago and I do not recall the names of the other pianists.
Let's talk music, no genre boundaries
This is an offshoot of the jazz thread. I and others found that we could not talk about jazz without discussing other musical genres, as well as the philosophy of music. So, this is a thread in which people can suggest good music of all genres, and spout off your feelings about music itself.
- ...
- 436 posts total
I'm sure she could be emotionally affecting on Chopin. On Mozart, however, I think, although I've never heard it said, that modern musicians are beginning to play him more emotionally. I have Fazil Say playing the sonatas and it's very different than Pires. But you don't have to be an aficianado to have your own taste. And your taste might change over the years. I listened to Mitsuko Uchida play Mozart's sonatas the other day and she did a lot of "interpretation." I liked it a lot. I like Pires, too. She makes Mozart sparkle. It's fun to listen to a few different artists and compare them. Mitsuko Uchida has specialized in Mozart, but that doesn't mean she's the last word, by any means. I really like some of Geza Anda's interpretations, and I think he plays Mozart more like Pires. What I consider to be a more "classical" style. I kind of like all of their interpretations. Like seeing Hamlet done by great actors. |
Great comparison! I like all the pianists mentioned here about Mozart or Chopin... And some others... My favorite Mozart and Chopin pieces though are played by Ivan Moravec ( One of my godly saint pianists). But he never did an integral though just few pieces but very well recorded (Nocturnes) and played with a majestic control of colors... |
**** I’ve never been a fan of the orchestra **** This cannot stand! 😊 Try these on for size: https://youtu.be/LqwZzPpxA0w?si=qJwSJytsc7GnU4b8 |
Good choices. I thought of recommending Bartok’s Concerto for Orchestra. I went to a live concert conducted by Dudamel. Fritz Reiner is my top choice for my album at home, but Dudamel did an excellent job. Reiner commissioned the piece and championed it. I thought it might have been a bit too dissonent for somebody finding their way into classical music, though.Thanks for the Hindemith piece. I’ve been trying to get to know his music better. Bernstein! Interesting. I’ll stream it. We were supposed to go to the Adams concert with Dudamel and Wang, but something happened (something always happens) and we had to exchange the tickets for something else. Now I’m really sorry I missed it. |
- 436 posts total