Hard Drive Question

Thanks Riffer. To be sure it's clear, what I was saying does not work through external drive interfaces is just the reading of SMART data. I know that is true for USB and Firewire, and I believe it is true regardless of whether HD Tune or any other comparable program is used. I suspect the same is also true with eSATA.

Most or all of HD Tune's other functions, including error scanning and speed testing, WILL work through USB and Firewire, and I assume eSATA as well.

Best regards,
-- Al

I'll second HDTune. I like how they highlight the troublesome SMART data in yellow.

You could also use Seatools, but I am always suspicious of utilities that are provided by the manufacturer.

I think HD Tune works with eSATA, but I don't have time to check right now.

Thank's Al. That's exactly what I was looking for.

Hi ZD,

I use the free (non-"Pro") version of the Windows-based program HD Tune. Among other features, it allows you to monitor S.M.A.R.T. data (health information provided by the drive) and to run an error scan in both quick and thorough modes.

S.M.A.R.T. data can't be read through external drive interfaces (USB, Firewire, and I believe eSATA), btw, so if you want to access that data (which I'd recommend) you'll have to install the drives internally (as a second or third hard drive) rather than installing them into an external enclosure.

Best regards,
-- Al