Free air, tighter bass - snake oil or cheap tweaks?


Usually when we talk about snake oil it's because some one is out to make a buck on the gullible.  In the case of these tweaks I want to recommend I'm not going to make any money, and you may not spend any either, but I find them useful.

Cover your Speakers

I don't know why a modest change in your acoustics can make such a difference but I usually find that covering my speakers adds a lot of air and room ambiance.  I like to use some thick curtains that I've had from a house a long time ago.  Works really well.

Weigh Your Speakers

I don't mean put them on a scale, but put a weight on top.  Of course, this doesn't apply to those with behemoths.  I find this especially useful with lightweight speakers that are on stands or very small footprints.  Think 2-ways, both bookshelf and floor standers.  I think the additional weight resists the tendency of the woofer to move the box back and forth, creating a kind of Doppler distortion in the bass. In some cases I find this tweak can really make a speaker sound tighter and clearer from the mid-bass downwards.

Clean up the Floor

We often pay attention to the walls, but not the floor, especially behind speakers.  I find that room treatment, cushions and blankets here can really cut out hash I didn't know I had. 

erik_squires

Showing 9 responses by erik_squires

So, to many I know this sounds like snake oil, but the weight has simple reason for working.  With smaller speakers, especially tall, narrow two-way speakers, the motion of the woofer pushes against the box, potentially causing a rocking back and forth effect.

This varies, of course, based on the height, weight and rigidity of the speaker.  For giant 200 lb rigid speakers there's no possible benefit here.

This does not have to be "tuned" because the issue isn't any one particular resonant frequency but the entire band of the woofer. 

@vitussl101  And have you all steal my ideas?? 🤣

 

Honestly though, this isn't an exact science.  Just drape absorptive cloth over the sides of your speakers and see if it helps.

I want to be clear, when I'm talking weight, I mean WEIGHT!!

Not "resonance dampers" or whatever those things are called.  Let's talk 20 lbs. or so.

 

@jayctoy As far as I'm concerned, any heavy weight (5 lbs or more) would work regardless of how fancy it is.  No need for a Magico brand.

@asvjerry - I think that the reason my curtain idea works is reflections coming off those flat hard surfaces.  If a speaker is a column shaped it's not going to have the same problems to begin with.

@asvjerry  If it's something like a Walsh speaker, the bass section provides plenty of area to cover, for an MBL though not so much.

@amtprod 

Take a blanket or curtain or something like that and drape it over your speaker so the top and sides are no longer visible. Leave the front exposed and the rear if ported.

@audiokinesis  Thank you. 

I have added felt around the front of speakers to good effect, so I can see how covering the front of a speaker in absorbent foam can work.  What I'm surprised at is that having a curtain that covers the top and sides works at all.  If asked to opine, I'd say that at best there would be some additional absorption in the room but not enough to matter.

PS - Focal speakers are great candidates for using PSA felt around the tweets.  Use a craft punch to make the hole and it looks pretty good.

@koestner:

 

I soon realized you didn't mean covering the front of the speakers, and the drivers.

 

Um, that's not what I meant, but this would be a great way of getting rid of sibillance problems.   🤣