Downsizing from tower to bookshelf


Moving to smaller home and need thoughts on bookshelf speakers. The new dedicated audio room is 12x14 and I plan to use the same wall/floor treatments I currently have in my 14x20 room.
I don’t live near a big city to go and demo, so I’d like to narrow down at least 3 speakers I can purchase and demo in the new room. I’ll send the others back once I find a winner.

Current equipment is;

VPI Scout with Hana SL

Parasound A21

Vincent SA32 Preamp

Elac PPA2 

Dyneaudio Emit 30

My preference is neutral to slightly warm sound with heavy emphasis on holographic soundstage. Price point is maxed at $3,500.
 

I was never really in love with the Dynaudio Emit 30’s but they did provide the neutral holographic soundstage I like. The only negative with the Dynaudio is they didn’t seem very dynamic or musical.i always felt they were missing something in terms of enjoyment. Maybe stepping up a model would help but I’m open to other brand suggestions.

My initial picks are;

Harbeth P3ESR XD

Revel M126Be

Wharfedale Aura 2

Any other recommendations would be appreciated.

 

vette5451

ATC SCM40 have the sound characteristics you’re looking for. Small footprint. Better bass than the stand mount speakers and within your budget used. 

there is usually one advocate for Fritz speakers, let me be him. I have his entry level, Fritz carbon 7 SE Mk2 model,  In a smallish room, 13x13' good amplification, good DAC and A SVS SB3000 sub, just for Rock and Roll,  and my favorite Pre Amp (have 2, one in my main system also, Benchmark LA-4. I believe he has a 30day trial. Go to his web site and take a look. I wouldn't trade mine for the world, like them that much. He also offers a upscale model with A BE tweeter. I will keep what I have. If you look, he has quite a following. Very high quality parts, and the woodworking is superb. Robert TN

Hello @vette5451 , So many choices!  I have recently come across Dynaudio's Contour 20i's and they are actually replacing a large pair of floor standers.  Why?  They sound better and have the desired looks and less visual impact in the family room.  I have my large Vivid Giya 2's downstairs, so this swap made my wife very happy. Sound better?  Yes!  Newer better tweeters is part of it, but the coherence from two drivers so close together is impressive.  With my pair of REL subs, bass is no issue.  I would look at used Contour 20's (under 2k) or the better newer Contour 20i's (used low to mid 3k with stands).  To compare with the Dynaudio Emit line is not fair.

I own the Studio Electric M4.   They are a great speaker.   Previous stand mounts were Revel M106 and PSB M2.   Both good speakers but the M4 in my opinion is much better. 

I replaced a pair of Omega Super Alnico with the M4 ,  just wasn't in love with the SAM.   My search for a compact monitor is over.  Awesome speaker.  Doesn't need a sub, but I use a small REL and it is amazing for a tiny system.