Do you grade your albums?


I've found tremendous bargains on CDs, SACDs and HDCDs at local thrift stores, usually less than $2 each. Some remastered, some original releases. 

I don't stream nor do I spin vinyl. My only source is an SACD/CD player that I enjoy very much.

I grade each of my 800 or so albums A+, A,B,C or D based on sound quality.

Parameters listened for are the usual stuff- clarity, timbres, soundstage, imaging, air, bloom, cohesiveness, dynamics.

Remastered almost always sounds significantly better than the original, especially if the engineer was Bob Ludwig. There are a others that are good too.

SACDs usually sound better than the standard "red book" versions, but not always.

Same thing for HDCDs.

Some artists do consistently class A sound, especially when remastered. Dire Straits, Depeche Mode, Supertramp, Pink Floyd, Enya, Steely Dan, Wang Chung, INXS, Bob Seger, ABC, Ozzy (yes, Ozzy!)...

For me, it's a lot easier to relax and enjoy the music when it's sound quality is classes A or A+. Class B is tolerable to listen to.

Classes C and D are mostly used to let a guest hear how bad they sound and then how much better classes B, A and A+ sound. Like hearing a different system, but it's not!

 

 Report this
 

tomcarr

I am just finishing putting all of my vinyl into the Discogs database. I have play graded them all based on condition. You can also "rate" them from 1-5 stars and make comments about sound quality, but I rarely do that.

My entire vinyl  collection (over 2k) is cataloged and graded as follows:

- Year of album

- Chronological number of album in artist discography

- Artist country of origin

- Country of specific pressing

- Chronological number of pressing

- Quality of pressing:

EQR= Exceptional quality recording

QR = Quality recording

All others not rated.

- Also making notes of better side to play with some description of the type of music played on obscure albums.

Example:

Red Hot Chili Peppers (USA) - Blood Sugar Sex Magik (5th album) Original 1991. EU press, 2nd pressing 2011. EQR. 

@mlsstl Me too. It hasn't been any trouble. I just give whatever I'm listening to a grade in my head. I don't make a list or anything like that. That would be too much work!

I agree that the quality of recordings varies enormously and is a major factor in how my system sounds. However, I haven't gone to the trouble of grading my local collection of about 6,000 albums. (I also have and use a Qobuz subscription which is fantastic for exploring new-to-me music.)

For me, the point of a recording is so that I can hear the music when I want. Sadly, some of my favorite music was recorded mediocrely, or even poorly. But, I still like those pieces and listen to them when that's what I'm in the mood for.

You exemplify the fact that the original recording quality is often more important for "hifi" SQ than components or cables.