2. speakers
  3. 135030-33962

Comparing Ribbon Tweeters - Golden Ear vs. Ascend Sierra

Hi - has anyone compared side by side the AMT ribbon tweeter in any Golden Ear vs. the RAAL tweeter in the Ascend Sierra speaker?  Or others like the Emotiva folded ribbon?  

I have auditioned the Golden Ears and like the tweeter but don't like other aspects of the speaker like the subwoofer, so wondering whether the Sierra's tweeter is close or comparable in providing a non-fatiguing and detailed experience.  

Thanks for any comments 
kansas400

Showing 3 responses by erik_squires

erik_squires
16,644 posts
 
Do not underestimate the waveguide on the revels. You get very good and controlled off axis response.

Would I trade my current AMT speakers for a Revel? Never. :)

Best,

E
erik_squires
16,644 posts
 
The dispersion of any radiating surface is related to the frequency and dimensions of the radiator. AMT’s are typically wider than ribbons, but they come in a variety of lengths. Some shorter than ribbons, some longer. 

Also, I don’t think limited dispersion is a negative at all, unless you happen to have a perfectly tuned room. :)

And yeah, the better one's have amazing dynamic range with little distortion or compression. 
erik_squires
16,644 posts
 
I love good AMT’s, but the range of quality in the tweeters and their implementation varies a great deal. The Golden Ear loudspeaker I heard with AMT tweeters was among the very worst I’ve ever heard.

In terms of tweeter brands, I consider Raal (true ribbons), Mundorf and Beyma (AMT).

There is some debate as to whether some true ribbon tweeters add a little distortion and coloration we find pleasant. An artificial sense of "air." 

If you are interested in the parts, more than the speaker brand, I suggest you talk to Fritz. Great speakers with top notch parts at very reasonable prices. http://www.fritzspeakers.com/

If you must have a Raal, Selah Audio has a long history of speakers with them. http://www.selahaudio.com/

Best,

Erik
More to discover