2. analog
  3. 194186-168327

Cartridge Upgrade Recommendations

Hello fellow audiophiles,

I've recently found myself gravitating back to vinyl and streaming less, which has reignited my passion for analog listening. As a result, I'm considering upgrading my cartridge..

Current Setup:

  • Turntable: Rebuilt Garrard 301

  • Tonearm: Ortofon TA-210

  • Cartridge: Ortofon Quintet Blue MC

  • Phono Cable: Ortofon

  • Phono Stage: Synthesis 79DC

  • Preamp: Synthesis 117DC

  • Power Amplifiers: Synthesis 98DC monoblocks

  • Speakers: Audio Note AN-E LX HE Hemp

  • Cables: Mix of Audio Note Lexus and AudioQuest​

I appreciate the warmth and weight that my current setup provides, but I feel there's more detail and clarity to be uncovered. Occasionally, the sound seems slightly veiled or muted, lacking the intricate details I'm seeking. I suspect that the stock tubes in my phono stage might be contributing to this, and I plan to experiment with some vintage 12AX7 and 12AU7 tubes from my collection when time permits.

I had my sights set on the Koetsu Rosewood Signature, but with recent price increases, it's become a more significant investment. My budget is around $4,000, though I'm open to stretching it if it leads to a substantial improvement. I'm aiming for a cartridge that maintains warmth and weight but also brings enhanced detail and clarity to the forefront.

My musical tastes are quite eclectic, ranging from Nine Inch Nails to the Grateful Dead, Charles Mingus to RÜFÜS DU SOL, and Muddy Waters to Beck. That said, I predominantly listen to jazz, vocals, and acoustic music on vinyl.

I'm open to purchasing used equipment but have reservations about used cartridges due to potential wear and unknown history.

I would greatly appreciate any recommendations or insights you might have regarding cartridge options that align with my preferences and system. Your collective wisdom is invaluable as I navigate this upgrade.

Thank you in advance for your guidance!

 

John

curtisvill
karl_desch's avatar
karl_desch
453 posts
 

@curtisvill. Proper cartridge mounting is a big topic.  I would try to find a local shop that you would trust to do it, whatever cartridge you decide on.  Many of us on Agon have invested time and money to learn how to do it ourselves.  There are many excellent tools our there (SmartTractor, Wally Tools) but if you just want to have it done right once then get an expert to do it for you. If you see yourself changing cartriges frequently for fun, then dive into learning how to do it.

Don't be afraid of used carts from respected sellers. It is a good gateway to nice SoundSmith, Koetsu,  Dynavector, AudioTechnica and Ortofon cartridges that have been mentioned in this thread. There really isn't one best cartridge just different.  Its your ears and system that count. Too bad for our pocket books, the only way to really know is to try them out.  I would look for a used Koetsu and dont look back.

drbond
441 posts
 

I've listened to Linn, Lyra, Koetsu, and My Sonic Lab in my system.  While each are slightly different, I would be very happy with any of those brands, and probably many others!  

curtisvill OP
65 posts
 

I am curious what you would do in this situation.
 

I have found a Koetsu Rosewood signature that has recently been re-tipped for $3150. I would need to find someone to come and help me set up my cartridge as I have never done that.
 

Option two is a brand new Rosewood Koetsu rosewood from my local shop. Most everything I have in my system has come from them and I value the relationship tremendously.
 

I do not know the sonic differences between the Rosewood and the Rosewood signature and would appreciate any insight as to the differences. I know I may be overthinking this, really appreciate your help. This is not only about equipment, it is also about a relationship. 

karl_desch's avatar
karl_desch
453 posts
 

I would start with a new Rosewood purchased from the shop that can get it mounted for you.  Hopefully they will know how it mares with your tonearm which a fear may need more mass to take advantage of the low compliance Koetsu. You are in for a treat.

curtisvill OP
65 posts
 

So I went with what @karl_desch recommended and purchased the Koetsu rosewood from my local shop, the owner and his son just left after installing it on my turntable. All I can say is WOW! The depth, weight, and detail is simply stunning. I am amazed at how quiet it is while listening, just silent background. Very happy with my purchase. Happy listening. 

More to discover