Cartridge for Denon DP 3000 NE


Hello everyone,

I decided to upgrade my turntable in part because a persistent hum associated with the white cartridge wire kept defeating my best efforts, & that ProJect Carbon Debut tonearm wasn't readily re-wireable. Anyway, I got a very good deal on a new Denon as above. I attached my Ortofon 2M Black with some difficulty because it doesn't fit easily into the Denon shell. But I got it in, calibrated. All good. Until I noticed one channel played very faintly. I checked the anti-skate, vertical tracking & stylus force ... nothing had any impact. I swapped the Ortofon for a Grado Gold. That played both channels, but with a terrible hum, which I could not eradicate. Finally I put in an old Ortofon OM which I'd got with my first turntable. That played fine.

 

Incidentally, (or not), I use a small Parasound phono stage as well, which connects to the aux 1 on my Rogue Audio Cronus Magnum II. Connecting directly to the Cronus phono jacks made no difference in how the Ortofon 2M played, but with the Grado Gold the hum disappeared, but it also failed to play both channels. With the Ortofon OM there was a slight hum when connected directly to the Cronus, but which disappeared entirely played through the Parasound. 

 

So I guess my question is, before I go & buy an expensive cartridge that doesn't work right, are there cartridges that simply aren't compatible with a unit such as the Denon? My Ortofon 2Ms (I have the black & the red) were getting due to be replaced at this point anyway, so I don't mind investing in a new one. I just want to be certain it will work correctly.

 

Many thanks....

andykatz

Showing 3 responses by lewm

Raul, I am not absolutely certain, but in re-reading the OP, it seems to me you can't blame all the problems on an incompatibility between the Grado cartridge and the new Denon TT. Seems he had issues with other cartridges as well. Depends I guess on what phono he is using in his first paragraph. But I agree, if the Parasound has a volume control (and sufficient phono gain), then there is no need for the Cronus to play LPs.

Intermittent problems like these are often the most difficult to diagnose and eliminate. Sometimes the physical acts required to change a cartridge or IC, the plugging and unplugging can create or mask the issue. Check the solder joints at cartridge clips. Check also inside your phono stage the connections between internal wires and the hot and ground nodes of the RCA jacks. For example take a tweezers and tug gently on those phono stage wires. Something’s going on somewhere.

"I decided to upgrade my turntable in part because a persistent hum associated with the white cartridge wire..." Maybe you should have investigated that phenomenon further before investing in a new TT. White wire usually carries left channel "hot", assuming you are not running in balanced mode. So one question is what made you conclude that the white wire was involved in causing hum? If the left channel hot wire was in contact with ground, due for example to a short circuit inside the tonearm wand, that would usually result in no signal at all, not hum. But there are some other scenarios that might result in hum.

You go on to write, after purchasing the Denon TT, that, "I noticed one channel played very faintly. I checked the anti-skate, vertical tracking & stylus force ... nothing had any impact." Once those remotely possible causes of reduced gain in one channel were eliminated, did you check to see if the reduced gain could have been also related to wiring? If so, was the reduced gain in the L channel, by any chance? Anyway, since this problem occurred with the new Denon turntable, the scant evidence suggests that both the hum and the loss of gain might be due to an issue downstream from the TT/tonearm. Additional evidence to support that idea is your finding that when you switched to a Grado Gold cartridge, you now had equal gain in both channels but "terrible hum". In this process, have you checked your phono ICs or the input jacks on your phono stage? What I am getting at is that you charged forward, and continue to do so, without investigating the causes of the hum, dropout, and etc, that you are experiencing.