Turntable Swamp. . .what to buy?


So, I have gotten overwhelmed with trying to decide on which turntable I want. I currently have an 1980's AR "The Turntable" with original AR arm and no mods. It has exposed me to the natural sound of analog. This is my only analog experience thus far. So, of course, I want to upgrade to something capable of more resolution. When I place new pressings on the AR I can tell I am missing something.

My current system consists of a Primaluna Prologue 2 w/onboard phono, Custom Eton 2-ways with 8inch midwoofers and tweets, Blue Jeans cables, and an AT 440mla cartridge.

The choices I have narrowed it down to are:

-Michell Tecnodec, love the look, users seem to be happy, but not a lot of info and difficult to find used so far.
-Nottingham Horizon, same as above.
-Rega P25 like the look, but pricey and a hassle to upgrade to the TTPSU that everyone seems to insist on as an upgrade.
-Rega P5 seems solid and liked but not so attractive.
-Rega RP6, dressed up P3-24, some say it sounds lean.
-VPI Scout, some grumbles about the tonearms, otherwise a good performer, kind of ugly.
-VPI Traveler, can get a used scout for the same cash and there seems to be confusion v1&2.
-Send my AR to VinylNirvana for an overhaul, price could approach or exceed the above tables.

So, I am all twisted up trying to decide which one to purchase? Your advice is appreciated.
djwilbourn
You can't go wrong with any of the TT's you are considering. That said, I say get a VPI Scout. The price is excellent for what you get and the upgrades are excellent as well. You should never need another TT. There's nothing wrong with the arm, either. You can get one from Music Direct. I've bought some stuff from them. You can get a good deal but don't count on good service. If you have to go mail order, Larry at Hollywood Sound in FL would be a better choice if you want good advice and help with setup. Also, I've been to his store. I'm pretty sure he has every TT on your list in stock ad on display.
If you do not like the JMW unipivot arm, you can also get the Scout with the Traveler arm for the same price. Matt Weisfeld posted a picture of it on Facebook and I asked him if it is available and the price.
Thanks for the help so far. No way to audition anywhere close. Birmingham, AL. We have Best Buy and Radio Shack. Great city, no brick and mortar audio though.
+1 Zd542.
Go to Hollywood and listen to them. Even if you fly, you'll loose a lot more $$ if you buy one you're not happy with. Or you could drive and have an expert set up your choice and bring it back. Keep the UPS gorillas away from your 'table.
The Vinyl Nirvana overhaul is not a bad idea. A friend here locally bought an AR table from Dave and it was an excellent table. I would also add SOTA to your list. They are under valued and you can go direct to SOTA and talk to them about some of their refurbished tables. Something like an older Star or Star Sapphire can be had for a very good price. They are quite stunning to look at too in those wood finishes. My old Nova Series V had a beautiful cherry finish and sounded great to boot.