Mono Cartridge Question


You chaps have watched me struggle with the issue of my London Decca Reference being irreplaceable, and then joyfully learning that John Wright has a successor after all. You have seen me buy and test three other MI designs (Nagaoka MP-500, Grado Statement3, Soundsmith Sussurro MkII) along with my older MC cartridges (Ortofon Kontrapunkt C and Benz Micro Ruby 3). Since those struggles have led me to owning two SME turntables and four tonearms, I am now torturing myself with the question of whether one of those four should be home to a dedicated mono cartridge. Remember, I only have one ear and cannot hear stereo at the best of times. A mono cartridge for my few dozen mono recordings would be a matter of reduced surface noise and possibly some improvement in dynamics.

I can get hold of an Ortofon Cadenza Mono (two voice coils so not true mono) for about 1600CDN, and a Miyajima Zero for 3450CDN. So the question is this: am I mad to even think about it? Money is not what it once was before I retired. There is no opportunity to go and hear these before purchase, without spending much more than purchase price on travel.

Shall I "make do" with my rather good stereo carts for my mono LPs or is there something better waiting for me when I get out those Parlophone Beatles LPs?

 

dogberry

I like both mono and stereo recordings, to be sure, but hearing a great mono record on a good system does make one wonder how far we have come ,;)

I have 1mil Miyayima Zero and it is amazing! So much better than stero carrridges on mono.

Mono cartridges simply work better on mono records.  Quieter, more presence.  The Miyajima is a true mono and would be the best choice of those you are considering.

All of you guys who extoll the virtues of using a mono cartridge on a mono LP, do you have a mono switch on your linestage?  And if so, do you hear a difference between the mono switch used with a stereo cartridge vs a mono cartridge?  My opinion is I get a large fraction of the benefit by just using a mono switch, and the trade-off with a mono cartridge is that the cartridge must compete against your stereo cartridge for overall SQ.  Thus with an inferior mono cartridge, you might taking two steps forward and one step backward.  (Or something like that.)