2. analog
  3. 180349-162159

Which needle for sony xl-45 cart, NOS or Jico sas?

 

Hello,

I happen to have a sony xl-45 cartridge w/o needle.

It is said to be vere good. Is it really so?

Well, now I need a needle.

And there two options

Either I can get a NOS vintage sony nd-45E (elliptical) for smth 230 or so usd

Or I can buy a brand new JICO sas for some 280 usd, i suppose .

What would be a better choice ?

Besides there a jico sas with boron cantilever and with a ruby one (a bit more expensive, about 350 usd)
Does it (cantilever) make a big diffrence and is ruby cantilever  is worth extra money ?

 

Thank you

serge8
Ag insider logo xs@2x
rauliruegas
12,823 posts
 

@serge8  : Not this that comes with elliptical stylus shape. The Sony original is the:

ND-45X, so maybe that seller could find out one for you.

 

R.

serge8 OP
22 posts
 

I see.... well,

There is indeed  such a needle also

is that the best one ?

 

serge8 OP
22 posts
 

And will it be better than a Jico sas boron?

Ag insider logo xs@2x
rauliruegas
12,823 posts
 

Dear @serge8  : That's the one . Jico is to expensive and up to you. I can't judge about.

 

R.

dover
2,182 posts
 

There is one significant advantage the SAS has - it's new. No time for the rubber to deteriorate.

The original Sony composite aluminium/carbon fibre cantilever is a key ingredient in achieving that neutrality. With the SAS the sapphire cantilever would be much closer in sound to the original than the Boron.

With regards to the stylus shape - the SAS is probably better than the original.

On the Sony XL55mkII Sony moved to using a micro ridge profile.

More to discover