Will a new Dac improve the sound?


I have an older CD player( Cary CDP1) . It sounds good ,but would a new or used Dac in the line improve the sound? Looking at Dacs in the $600 - $1200 range. I know the other equipment would also matter in the outcome, but as a general question......do you think this would be an upgrade to the sound? Or should i go another route?

GP

garypick

I bought an Emotiva ERC 4 CD player. Its $600. It has an excellent DAC. I think you would be surprised with the quality of the sound you get with the built-in DAC. Why not try it. It comes with it for free. I upgraded to an Ares II and it sounds better, not night and day better, but noticeably better. I also noticed an improvement with Audioquest interconnects. My advice is get the ERC 4 and new speakers. If you don't like it add the Ares II. 

I tried a few DACs recently and found the Denafrips ARES II a major improvement  and a keeper.  I went computer audio from my YBA Design CDP  in 2016 and have auditioned a number of DACs. ARES is around $850 from Singapore.  Lots of reviews on it.

The Ares II is a fantastic DAC but I quickly uograded to the Pontus !!. Superb. Both tacks seem to handle treble naturally and the bass is much tighter and better defined.

@garypick - one more thought - if it were me, I would not introduce tubes into the equation at the DAC itself. Seems more logical to implement tubes at the preamp or amp - in any event, let us know what you decide to do!

I have the best DAC I have owned, the Audio Research Reference 9 CDse. I had the $22K Berkley Alpha Reference 3 DAC in my system and the sound was really really really close… a tiny itsy bit different… the ARC was a touch warmer and the Berkeley a tiny more detailed (took hours of critical listening to be sure). This is an all ARC Reference system that is extremely detailed, and natural sounding to start with. See, my user ID.

On the other hand I had a very good high end Sim Moon DAC and it was thin and cool in comparison (this is a good DAC… we are talking about high performance stuff)… I said in comparison.

A high quality tubed component is a thing of beauty. But it is one component in the signal path. A very good one to have tubed… but so is a Preamp, and amp. To have a really natural and complementary system, all tubed gear is a good way to go. Not the only way.