2. analog
  3. 162108-145800

Cartridge forgiving of "non-audiophile" recordings and pressings

I’m a record collector first, and I have stacks of vinyl of many genres that would never qualify as audiophile quality, either in terms of recording, pressing, or both. Note that this isn’t a problem of vinyl condition. We’re talking VG+ at worst.

I find that the various fine line styli are too fussy and revealing with these records. Nude elliptical have proven to be a better match here, a good compromise.

Anyway, I’m looking to explore some new carts in a second system and wanted some recommendations. I know it all comes down to subjective listening, but I like to hear about what others have experienced as a guide to exploring.

I want a forgiving cartridge but with good dynamics and a fast transient response. Quick, full, tuneful bass and rich mids are the priority over treble extension and detail.

For now, ignore tonearm effective mass, turntable, etc. Budget up to $1,000. MM or MC.

Thanks all.

128x128funthings
yeti42's avatar
yeti42
287 posts
 
Ortofon SPU seems cope fairly well with scratches. I use the Royal N which does have a fine line stylus but some say its not a real SPU. The spherical or eliptical might suit your needs better.
I decided to try one after reading this blog
https://medialux.blog/2018/04/
along with some of Art Dudley’s writings.

gordon
128 posts
 
I’m listening to the Melvins using a Dynavector XV-1s.  The sound is great.  I can recommend whichever DV cartridge is in your price range.
belyin
61 posts
 
If you have an appropriate tonearm, I second the SPU recommendation. I consider myself more a music fan and record collector than an audiophile, and I find the SPU really suits my needs. I do have "more advanced" designs, but I keep going back to the SPU. If you of many mono recordings, it will handle those well too--especially if you have a mono switch on your preamp.
gregm
3,395 posts
 
I agree that the better the rig the better the sound. 
In that light, MMs with excellent tracking will do the job well within your budget, such as the Dynavector above, a Shure V15, an AT, an Ortofon 2M black or Cadenza bronze / black, or the recommended Clearaudio.
audionoobie's avatar
audionoobie
355 posts
 
I have to disagree with @gregm's suggestion of the Ortofon 2M Black. With its Shibata stylus profile it is ruthless in terms of showing off any and all warts on vinyl that is in less than pristine condition. It is a good cart though. 
More to discover