Focal 1028BE2's or Tekton Moab Towers


Hi - I'm fairly new to the hobby, I've always really enjoyed listening to music but at home was more focused on Home Theater.  Over the last several years I've shifted my focus to 2 channel listening, upgraded my amp, pre and DAC/Streamer. 

Currently I have Focal 1028BE's, a Primaluna Evo 400 integrated amp, REL TI9, Lumin D2 with Sbooster upgrade.  I stream Tidal 99 % of the time and on rare occasion will pop in a CD.  I've also had HAF create some filters in Roon as well.
At times my gear sounds really, really good, other times, specifically with Rock and poor recordings it can be bright, harsh, fatiguing.  Prior to the Primaluna I had a Parasound A21 and P6 combo.  My room is large, man cave, finished basement, open except for the staircase that splits up the room.  It's a shared space, HT, sectional couch, Pool Table, arcade games with an office tucked in the corner.  Acoustic drop ceilings are 8 feet, flooring is vinyl / blank style, area rug in the seating area, leather sectional couch.  I sit around 12 feet from the towers, the sectional splits up the space, there is another 20 feet or so of open space behind the sectional.  I can't really room treat, that's the one spot my very understanding wife won't let me go.

So, I've seen a lot of posts about Tekton and Moab's with commentary that they are less fatiguing, easy to drive speakers that punch far above their weight class, are great with Rock.  Negatives I've read are size, they are huge, fit and finish isn't up to the same standard as other manufacturers.  Some have stated they didn't get a full, robust sound that most describe, saying the speakers are thin, not very cohesive. 

I chose the 1028's because they punched above their weight, with the trickle down effect offering some of the features in the Utopia series along with Focal's reputation for building and designing everything in house.  I got the 1028's last year, several audiophiles said Focal had taken them out of the line up and with them gone the jump to get the BE tweeter and W Cone in the Focal line up was a big one price wise with the 1028 and 1038's being discontinued.  I also read they are one of the largest speaker / driver suppliers to other manufactures.  Common sense would tell me Focal's should be a better speaker.  Reviews I've read rave about Tekton's and specifically seem to reference the Moab's as being the best speaker in returns to diminishing returns in the line.

I'm a novice, just stayed at a Holiday in Express last night, would I be crazy to sell my Focal's and buy the Moab's or would it take my sometimes great sounding set up to a sounds great with everything?
mm1tt77
Any poorly recorded music will sound that way on even the best speakers a speaker that masks this just isn't that good. 
Mission, you must mean the small hundreds of happy customers posting their positive thoughts on Tekton’s? That small handful? Lol. Table, you just ha e to decide what’s more important, sound or looks, though neither one sounds bad. To me the focals aren’t going to win any beauty contests either, just the simple box tower, just not as bulky for sure. The larger cabinets I’m sure are part of what gives them more umph down low. Either way, no wrong choices really, just which one works best all things considered, for each person. 
Thanks for all the responses!  Sounds like the Focal’s and Tekton’s are two very different beasts or maybe more appropriately Beauty and the Beast.  
Good advise that not every recording is going to sound good. 

I’ll continue to play around with speaker placement.   Would love to hear the Tekton’s in my set up but not sure if I’ve got the energy and fortitude to lug them up and down the stairs that lead to the man cave.  Or take the risk that I damage them in some way and can’t return them.  Also have a bit of a mental block wondering how they could be as great as advertised, feels a bit like an infomercial, as seen in TV type product - absolutely not trying to offend anyone as reviews and loyalty to the brand would validate they are that good.  

I’ll keep reading the thread and see if it motivates me to pony up to try the Moab’s.

Side note - conceptually the McIntosh Towers have a similar driver layout to the Moab and Tekton speakers - anyone ever compare those to Tekton’s? 
I will preface this by saying I have listened to those speakers and they are not my favorite.  Focals are going to be a bit bright relative to other speakers (not a bad thing, so are some of the ones I make) and the right thing to do is pair with a warmer amp...which you have done via the Primaluna. That amp should leave them relatively neutral sounding.  I am surprised you are still having an issue with brightness after moving away from Parasound.  

In terms of sound, I like a slightly forward sound that is very detailed without crossing over to shrill.  Means there is amazing sparkle in piano but horns and strings don't sound more metallic and shrill than they should.  It is a fine line.  

How well damped is your room?  Increasing damping would be the place I would look to make a change and that may resolve the issue you are having.  Otherwise, you would need to look for a warmer speaker or a warmer amplifier.  

I have not heard the Tektons and can't speak about their sound profile and whether it will be an improvement for your specific issue.  
Post removed