When a budget speaker is preferred to a high end one...


How many have experienced a situation when a more budget oriented speaker has a more preferred overall sound over a higher end speaker, something at 3 or more times the price?  What are your thoughts, experiences and how can you explain this?

agwca

Showing 2 responses by waytoomuchstuff

Outstanding posts!

If I recall correctly,the Dahlquist DQ-10 used a $5 Motorola piezo as a "super tweeter". Not many of us will dispute the legitimacy of this speaker as one of the most impactful speakers of our time. Genius has a way of leap frogging price barriers. You may remember a young man who built a 700 watt power amp inside a Folgers coffee can years ago? Then there are those occasions where all the stars line up, and gifted hands (and, minds) are given the freedom to operate without limitations. This is where the ground trembles (sometimes, literally) in my view, and the "state of the art" takes a giant leap forward.

A couple more comments on "budget speakers":

As a modder/hot rodder of hifi gear, we learned pretty early that the raw drivers are not necessarily the weakest link in the chain. When things are removed/replaced that "make things sound worse" the sonic results can be stunning. When the audio signal is presented in very good shape to the tensil leads on the raw drivers, "audiophile characteristics" suddenly appear, and the magic happens. Very consistently.

@fsonicsmith Well done with the Advent and B&W mods. My guess is that they retained the sonic "personality" that you loved about them, but are now infinitely more musical. Money well spent.

John

@pcrhkr Your reference to the Ultralinear 100s brings back memories.

It was said that if you removed them from the carton and set them next to it and a big gust of wind came up, the speakers would blow away and the cartons would remain in place.

Industry Nickname: Ultrasloppy 100s

My own story:

I worked for a dealer and had a pair of these sitting on the highest shelf. We had a mishap and one of them fell off the edge of a shelf and landed squarely on top of a Pioneer HPM200. Being quite upset (it was my fault) I rushed over to check out the damage and discovered a totally disenintegrated Ultralinear 100 and a PIoneer HPM200 without a scratch. True story.