That sixties/seventies sound was more a speaker thing IMO. That's how Bose got their popularity. Maybe try the JBL 12" 3-ways. The cart on its own won't take you there.
What is best turntable for listening to Rock from the sixties like Led Zeppelin?
The sound quality isn’t great, so rather than something super revealing, something that is very musical, and can also convey the magic. Sort of the Decca cartridge equivalent of turntables. I am guessing less Caliburn and Techdas, more Linn, Roksan, Denon, EMT 927, Rega, even.