Sorry, but it really depends on your price level and what sound quality you want. But, price point dictates everything. There are good to great cartridges within each price point range. I could be annoying and just list the most expensive cartridge and be done, but as with most of us, we have price limitations. In my humble opinion, the Sota Star Saphire is better by far than the VPI Scout. But, that is only my opinion. I have found that the SME IV, IV.IV or V arms are much better than the 309 and again depending on price, the IV is easily obtainable for not much. But, the 309 is a really nice arm also. But, do you want to spend <$1,000 or $1,000 to $2,000 or greater for the cartridge? can you borrow a cartridge from your favorite dealer to use for a week?
enjoy