Vibrating speakers


On another thread just now was a post by Geoff Kait

geoffkait
21,280 posts
04-18-2020 3:45pm
+1

“The only good vibration is one that’s dead.” - Shannon Dickson

Yes, I know what some of you are thinking, “but speakers are like musical instruments. They’re supposed to vibrate!”

Is this so - are speakers supposed to vibrate? I thought it was just the drivers, and the speaker shouldn't.
Or am I missing something?
Hence I use Townsend Podiums for main speakers regardless of floor type
tatyana69

Showing 1 response by erik_squires

Imagine making a speaker attempting to get the same sonic behavior as a violin. Well, that's great, but how do you deal with a drum, a sax, the human voice, bells?  Yes, some instruments are made of wood, but many are not.

The speakers should not add any unintended sonic signature. I say "unintended" because some speakers have a house sound which is achieved through a variety of means, and I imagine cabinet construction is one of them.

Ideally, these vibration controls occur:

  • The cabinet does not vibrate
  • The cabinet does not transmit vibration to the floor, which then re-radiates into the room
  • The speaker itself is fixed in all three dimensions
The last one is why adding mass to the top of a monitor can help.


Having said this, there is some research related to controlling, instead of eliminating, vibration altogether. I don't remember much about it, but it's a compromise brought on by the need to create affordable and relatively small and lightweight systems.