TUBE or SS PATHS


This came from my local Technician:  "  You all are enthusiasts of fine audio reproduction equipment, and of course, appreciators of fine musicianship. I'm curious of your thoughts concerning the reproduction of sound. As audiophiles, is it not the desire to faithfully reproduce and amplify the input signal without distortion of any kind? Why is it then, that some prefer tubes due to their "warm" personality, and others prefer the "sterile" personality of solid state? Indeed, if a fine audiophile grade tube amp and a fine audiophile grade solid state amp are compared side to side, should they not sound exactly the same? If they do not sound the same, I would say one of them, if not both are coloring and/or distorting in some form? I have posed this question to many of my "high end" customers, and have never gotten an answer that satisfies me.....your thoughts?  John

I have thoughts to share down the road.  More Peace, Pinthrift
pinthrift

Showing 1 response by glennewdick

Then there is who is designing your gear are they older with natural hearing loss or younger with much of their hearing still intact. that's something I've always wondered as many of our more famous designers are well past retirement age so their hearing is in question IMO. lets take for example a person reviewing some gear, what's that persons age ?do they have hearing loss ? that makes a huge difference in what they hear and what they report.  lets not even get into environmental influences. 

Someone with hearing loss in one area may report other areas next to those frequencies as elevated.  

Do you honestly think an elderly male is going to be able to hear much above 15k (if that) so how do they know if the treble is extended or not? or harsh or not? 

I'm 54 i know from testing that I have a slight loss at around 5-6khz in my left ear do I notice this when listening of course not my brain fills it in (probably not actually correct but that's our brains). 

Moral of the story we all hear differently so finding a designer with similar tastes and hearing is essential to our enjoyment. So get out there get your hearing tested correctly (not the push the button when you hear a tone test that's not accurate enough) find out were your lacking and use that information to help you select equipment. 

Glen