Toslink vs. Coaxial

Hasaw: You will probably get some widely varying opinions on this subject, but I have done a lot of A-B tests with both co-ax and TOSLINK cables, and can hear almost no difference between them. At the present time, I have a Pioneer Elite DV-37 DVD player connected to my Bryston SP-1 pre/pro using both TOSLINK and digital co-ax, and can thus switch back and forth between the two cables. In comparing one cable to the other, my friends also note virtually no consistently audible differences, except for slight differences in volume level (not sure why). I am using good quality cables in both cases: a Cardas digital co-ax cable, and Kimber's TOSLINK cable. Unless you are doing very critical, audiophile-type listening to music, I believe that either co-ax or TOSLINK will work fine for you, particularly in a home theater system.

Since you're new, you may want to try and use the search feature as you should be able to find many different comments on your question in other threads.

Well, all the manufacturers recommend coaxial over Toslink. So, why not use the coaxial?

Hasaw, This topic has been covered many times before, and the consensus is that coax is considered by 98% of the people to be better than Toslink, although I am sure that in sdcampbells particular circumstances that he is correct. You have some nice gear and I think if you were listening to good cables that you would hear a diference between Toslink and coax, but be careful, in 5.1 channel mode the difference is not as obvious as in stereo.

In my experience, coax is sonically better. If you use toslink, try Kimber Kable's. It is what I use in my car audio system.

Happy listening!

The superiority of one format ( coax ) over the other ( toslink ) is all equipment dependent. Under most circumstances, the coaxial SHOULD fare better due to having to go through two less converters. Using the coax, the digital signal from the transport remains digital and is fed directly into the digital to analogue converter. Using the Toslink, the transport must convert the digital signal into an optical signal and feed the Toslink cable. This in turn feeds the input of the external DAC which converts the optical signal back into a digital signal. More work and and a longer signal path typicall results in degradation of signal and resolution. This is not to say that the Toslink won't work okay, but you do have the opportunity for greater loss or increased colouration of the signal. Sean
>

Hasaw. Optical done properly will outperform coaxial, but doing optical properly is very expensive and rarely available in home audio. Toslink (as opposed to AT&T or Single Mode) is cheap stuff and is way short of what coaxial can achieve. The most obvious sound difference is that Toslink sounds smoother, but less detailed and thinned down. Recently manufacturers have begun to improve the quality of Toslink stuff and the new DACs are better at removing jitter. But you are still better off with a coaxial cable.

THANKS GUYS !!!,
I APRECIATE ALL THE INPUT. AND NEXT TIME I NOW KNOW TO USE THE SEARCH ENGINE.
LOOKS LIKE I NEED A TRANSPORT, SINCE MY ONKYO DOESN'T HAVE COAXIAL OUTPUTS.