Thin Line Between Critique and Courtrooms: A Dialogue on the Recent Audiophile Drama

@mahgister 

My sincere apologies to you.  I forgot that you know everything about audio (and almost everything about every other  thing).  Why do you waste your supremacy on such a trivial platform as this?  As others have asked, what is your point?  Oh never mind, I forgot, it's all about your ability to understand acoustics and the real meaning of life.

A review of a product, for example speakers, based on specs measures or in subjective impressions in a room , or the two together is always a debatable matter, because there is always many parameters, many different needs at play, the only exception is if the speakers are very bad design to begin with ...( but very bad speakers design do not go very far in sales)

then for me any reviews result as any design from a set of trade -off choices, in the designer intention as well as in the reviewers needs and wishes...

Where are the dots ?

If you look at one side they are there, if you look at the other side they are there...

there is no absolute truth in design no more than in reviewing...

Designer must not use threat of legal pursuit and reviewers must be cautious in their choice of words for sure ...

The extinction illusion: the left side and the right side have the same number of black dots...

In reality, both sides of the image contain the same number of black dots, but our brains' selective attention and processing mechanisms cause us to perceive them differently. This illusion highlights the complex interplay between perception, attention, and cognition in shaping our visual experiences.

@mahgister 

I repeat, " Why do you waste your supremacy on such a trivial platform as this?" 

Also, why do you have to impose your opinion on any subject?               

I will return back your question to yourself ? why do you need sarcasm instead of argument in an audio platform especially against someone as rational as atmasphere ?

For my mental health personal report , it is not for you here to have an answer...

This thread is about a precise matter which you can adress as i did myself and atmasphere with "arguments" and reason ...Not with insult, innuendos, sarcasms only and mainly ...

Anybody using arguments and reason here is welcome... Even me... 😁

By the way i never "impose" my opinion as you just did with your personal adress to atmasphere, me i always gave plenty of arguments and  anybody can reply with arguments  ... Nobody can give an argument as answer to sarcasm, as your useless pointing to atmasphere "ego" was...

is it clearer ?

I am not a perfect human being too  because i answered you ... 😊

@mahgister

I repeat, " Why do you waste your supremacy on such a trivial platform as this?"

Also, why do you have to impose your opinion on any subject?

@mahgister 

Another non-answer.  

I repeat, " Why do you waste your supremacy on such a trivial platform as this?"

Also, why do you have to impose your opinion on any subject?