Hey OP:
As you may have seen, to me the issue of integration of a sub is critical.
The sub must integrate to the speakers at the top of it's range, and the room everywhere else.
So, I strongly suggest before you start to talk to GIK Acoustics regarding room treatment, especially bass traps. This may solve your problem with your current sub, and make your current set up sound a lot better.
After this, consider a subwoofer only EQ. If you don't like that idea, then get your two REL subs, but I would strongly encourage you to make your room more speaker/sub friendly with room treatment if not already.
Best,
E
As you may have seen, to me the issue of integration of a sub is critical.
The sub must integrate to the speakers at the top of it's range, and the room everywhere else.
So, I strongly suggest before you start to talk to GIK Acoustics regarding room treatment, especially bass traps. This may solve your problem with your current sub, and make your current set up sound a lot better.
After this, consider a subwoofer only EQ. If you don't like that idea, then get your two REL subs, but I would strongly encourage you to make your room more speaker/sub friendly with room treatment if not already.
Best,
E