Stylus Force Guages - why extreme accuracy?


I am under the impression that, when setting up a phono cartridge, one sets the tracking force to the manufacturers recommended force, and then dial-in the final force by ear. If that is the case, then why are extremely accurate electronic stylus pressure gauges popular when the force is most likely going to change during final adjustment by ear? The Sure SFG-2, costing $25, has worked great for me to ball-park the initial tracking force before final tweaking. So, what benefit is the Winds ALM-01, costing $800, going to provide? Is it important to set the initial force to within a tenth of a gram, when that will change during final tweaking? What is the procedure those of you who own expensive gauges use for final adjustment by ear?
seasoned

Showing 1 response by mre2007

In my opinion, you can do pretty good with a 0.01g accuracy scale from Ebay (search 0.01g scale, mine has a stainless steel platform. More exactly, mine is item #190001314544) and a little jig such as this which can be made for a few dollars. The jig ensures the VTF measurement is made at the record's height, which is important and something that the more expensive, record-specific scales do. I also have a 50g (half capacity) and 100g (full capacity) calibration weights for my scale. After calibration, in fact multiple measurements taken on various parts of the scale are really within 0.01g, which is why I recommend that particular scale. In addition, my dealer used a Winds scale on my turntable recently, so I had a chance to compare the two methods. Mine was about 0.08g-0.1g different from his reading. However, after using the calibration weights on the Winds, it looks like it was off about 0.05g (at least compared to the calibration weights..), so I'd say they're really close. Close enough, that it could be due to the heights where the two measurements were made. The Winds scale was placed on top of a record, while my method measured the plinth to record height, removed the record, and then calibrated my jig to mimic the previous record height. I used a steel ruler to measure, and IMHO my method was a bit more accurate at measuring VTF exactly at the record level.

I hope this is helpful!
-Marc