Just got my Rhino High Fidelity Cars S/T in. Same problem as OP.
Rhino High-Fidelity record jackets
I just got 3 Doors titles on Rhino High Fidelity - they sound great, but the records fit into the jackets so tightly that it's a real struggle taking them out to begin with, and then putting them back in is even worse; I've already got a tear in one of the inner sleeves from jamming it in.
Anybody else have this problem and figure out a good solution? I've never experienced this with any other LP's, going back to the 60's, except for these Rhino High Fidelity ones.