The phono requirement makes this tough. Certainly, you're best off buying used to keep you whole when you re-sell to upgrade.
My first thought was to look for an original Audible Illusions Modulus 3 (not the 3a), but even those go for $500+. I've had both and I actually liked the phono better on the Modulus 3 than I do on my current Modulus 3a.
You might check out some semi-vintage stuff. The Yamaha C-5 preamp for instance falls into your price range (less!), and should be a good match with the McCormack. Has a pretty good phono stage too. A bit older, but maybe even better phono stage is the original Advent receiver, used as a preamp. This has a justly celebrated phono stage, and again fits your price range. You shouldn't lose money reselling either of these.
Another alternative is the Wright WPL100 preamp, which again is a bit above your limit. I had one of these and found it quite nice, if not quite high-end in sound quality. Again, the phono stage is the highlight. I think mine sold for $400 or so, IIRC.
It's a tough price range. Hope this helps!
Frank
My first thought was to look for an original Audible Illusions Modulus 3 (not the 3a), but even those go for $500+. I've had both and I actually liked the phono better on the Modulus 3 than I do on my current Modulus 3a.
You might check out some semi-vintage stuff. The Yamaha C-5 preamp for instance falls into your price range (less!), and should be a good match with the McCormack. Has a pretty good phono stage too. A bit older, but maybe even better phono stage is the original Advent receiver, used as a preamp. This has a justly celebrated phono stage, and again fits your price range. You shouldn't lose money reselling either of these.
Another alternative is the Wright WPL100 preamp, which again is a bit above your limit. I had one of these and found it quite nice, if not quite high-end in sound quality. Again, the phono stage is the highlight. I think mine sold for $400 or so, IIRC.
It's a tough price range. Hope this helps!
Frank