Power supply for ethernet switch?


Hi, All,

 

LOVING my DENAFRIPS Hermes/Pontus combo! WOW what a difference adding the Hermes made. I could not have been even hopeful for the improvement this made!

 

I just bought the TP Link TL-SG105 Ethernet Switch. I have been contemplating so many different paths here, including the setup from Small Green Computer with the Optical Module, power supply, etc. Very intriguing. But that's a little expensive and a lot of added wires,components, etc. I was also looking at the Silent Angel Bonn N8 switch...Would love to get some opinions on just adding a power supply to my new TP Link switch or would one of the other paths mentioned above be better?

 

If adding a power supply to the TP Link would be a worthwhile improvement, any recommendations, maybe even the 5V power supply from Small Green Computer?

Thanks in advance for your time and advice😊

kingbr

Showing 5 responses by mgrif104

There is some data to help answer the question of whether or not a quality switch can make a difference. 

https://www.alpha-audio.net/background/hard-evidence-a-network-affects-playback-quality/

Some will still disagree or remain skeptical about 30 picosends of timing error being audible. So be it. But I would suggest that it’s no longer worth arguing over. It can be measured and some of us hear the improvement.

Best, 

@richardbrand

I’m aware of how the data is handled. However, I’ll just go back to what I posted:

“Some will still disagree or remain skeptical about 30 picosends of timing error being audible. So be it. But I would suggest that it’s no longer worth arguing over. It can be measured and some of us hear the improvement.”

Best,

@richardbrand 

curious. - I don’t know why the picosecond didn’t copy over from my post. Another mystery.

As to your question - I won’t venture an answer as I’m not the author of that material. The point the author was making is that a switch indeed introduces measurable jitter.  

Before this study, many believe they heard improvements from upgraded switches. I acknowledge it could still be placebo, but at least we now can begin to consider potential deleterious effects of jitter with some supporting data.

The point I was trying to make is that it’s not worth spending time on as it’s a circular argument.  A point you seem to find unsatisfying.

Despite the well-meaning intentions of those who wish to help prevent us from spending money unwisely, I recently purchased the Reiki Audio switch and upgraded power supply through Liquid Hifi. (See: reikiaudio.com) It seemed more thoughtfully designed and built than the others I considered, other than the one from Taiko.

Newly installed, it brought a sizable and unmistakable improvement over my previous switch - the English Electric.  

I don’t think expensive network switches are for everyone. They range from an expensive accessory to very expensive accessory. And I can imagine some home networks will benefit more than others, some less, based on the many variables present. Nevertheless, for me, it was an entirely reasonable and worthwhile investment.

YMMV. 

@mclinnguy 

I wasn’t familiar with them either until about a month ago. But a fair amount of digging and consideration for what each respective firm was doing led me in this direction. I think they’re all trying to reduce EMI noise and use improved power supplies. Reiki and Ron Buffington at Liquid HiFi - the dealer I worked with (recommended) were better able to make that case.

I’m quite pleased with the results.

Best,