No "Room Correction" Topic option. Why?


I wanted to pose a question on room mods but do not see a logical place
to insert it so I am going with "Speakers" as a good, wrong choice.
Moderators, can you attend to this deficiency? 

My question: I am redoing my listening room in several ways.
Not because it was bad-quite the contrary. But because the room 
was a dark hole so I bought three new windows and replacement door.
The existing wall allowed rain water in from the patio floor outside.

 I started dismantling a 20' section of wall. As I opened the wall i found the
existing base plate-not treated wood, to be dust. Then mold on the drywall.
then termite evidence. 

Once the old crap was gone, I poured a concrete base plate 20 feet and another 6 feet
on the return. Termite damage had trashed the double sill plate and parts of two joists.

With all the wiring exposed I discovered an abandoned 220 a/c line buried in the wall.
Voila!  I had 2 dedicated 110v outlets for another part of the room. 

Might as well add 5 can lights while I was at it.

I upgraded the Streaming ethernet line from cat 5 to cat 7. Might as well
since I had sawsalled thru the old line. 
Then I learned that fiber is a better bet so I will be changing that later.

Another find! A buried abandoned entry door offering a 30" x 80" x 10" shelving
opportunity! 

I started this task by removing the old carpeting.

Now to my question. 

Shall I go with new porcelain tile flooring and plan on area rug -or-
put carpet back for its superior sound absorbing properties?

I hope someone out there has been down this road and has
an experience to share?

Thank you!


chorus

Showing 2 responses by mikelavigne

in 2004 i wrote an article on Positive Feedback online about building my room. it does address some of your concerns.

http://www.positive-feedback.com/Issue16/lavigneroom.htm

i’m actually embarrassed to read some of what i wrote then, now 16 years later. i did not know then what i did not know. i have changed many things about my room since then, you can see it here.

https://systems.audiogon.com/systems/615

and the 3400+ posts attached to that room description does document many of my changes over the years. it was not a linear experience. but i enjoyed every minute of it, and still spend 30+ hours a week in my room. so my ROI is spectacular!!!

know that building a room and then getting the maximum performance from it is more about you and learning than about gear or nails, sheet rock and power grids.

best wishes with your room building process.
Mike-Looking thru your component list, can you tell me if
the room correction equipment was a truly worthwhile
move?

@Chorus
when you use the term ’room correction equipment’ it’s unclear your intent. i view that term as some sort of DSP (digital signal processing) that adjusts your music to fit into the room acoustics. i don’t use that approach.

my room is about being designed to be acoustically friendly with it’s shape, surfaces and method of construction. so no messing with the signal path. i keep my signal path all analog. i do have analog adjustments for my bass towers to optimize bass performance in room.

to answer your question; yes for sure, i do think my efforts to optimize the music performance in my room by making the acoustical changes was worth while. part of those efforts is the balance between the carpet section for the floor, and the hardwood under the speaker end. i also filled in my windows with inserts. and these things are only briefly touching the surface of all the things i’ve done over my 16 years in the room.

all that said; i think the most important tool to find musical harmony in any room is a musical reference in your head that you are striving for. or; delegate that role to someone you trust. it’s all about the room meeting your expectations.

and......if you are not clear what you want.......drum roll please......then you have no business trying to build a dedicated room. how could you even know where you are going? find reproduced music that is doing what you want. get a solid memory of that, and then find that same type sound in your room. that is the proper way to judge results. listening. you might need to revisit that reference sound a couple of times to recalibrate your ears as time goes by as you are working toward that goal. everyone is different as to how easily they can retain their aural memory.

and be prepared for the fact that as you evolve in your hifi hobby time and listen more your tastes and expectations will likely change, and what you expect from your room will evolve with you. and you will be able to make adjustments as you go along.

measurements are useful for problem solving, but proof of concept is what you hear.