both are dandy tables, but there are lots of used tables in their (used)price range that compete favorably. if you don't have a large record collection, or it will be a secondary source, they are both fine. if you are determined to grow a large collection of lps, i would also look at nottingham, linn, townshend, sota, thorens (old models only) oracle, yada yada, before purchasing. of the two (stock), the michell gets the nod, but its close.....the basic scout rarely satisfies a vinyl junkie for long...something vpi hopes will send you back for upgrades.