Magnepan 3.5r Owners needed.... No bass

@nevada_matt 

Physically I did not like the fact that maggies being about the size of most doors, cut my room off. My personal preference is for a much shorter speaker. enter Emerald Physics OB 3.4s which throw as big of a sound stage as my Maggie 3.5Rs, but visually opened up the room (see my Virtual System). Now, if you want more bass they made a version of the 3.4s with both 1 and 2 @ 15" bass drivers.

No longer made but they do come up for sale from time to time at super cheap prices

hth

Underwood HIFI has an Emerald Physics page that says “new models in late March 2023”

Emailed for an update.

Still, any magnepan owners out there who could chime in on minimum level model to handle 900watts/channel, without blowing up or distorting?

@nevada_matt 

My old listening room for years was 24' wide by 34' long.  Vaulted ceilings. 

Best listening room I've ever been in due to wall materials and some other factors.  I HIGHLY recommend Magnepans for a room like the one you're describing.  

They have serious potential when given the space and not crowded with other things.  Other than a few plants, I had nothing else behind the speakers.  My components were off to the side, which is preferable to between speakers.  When I had that setup, I auditioned many expensive setups and in my head would always think(these don't come close to my system at home.)  I didn't always say it because you don't want to insult someone else's setup that they're enjoying.  And they were some really great rigs.  

But it literally took an $85,000 rig to get into the range of realism and Natural detail that I was getting.  

My point - the room is everything with Maggies and I think most people overlook this.  The room I am currently in is not 30% of what I used to get in my old house.  

But that is what happens when you move to the city.  Unless you have a huge loft or something.  Which many people do have.  

Sound stage in my old room was unlike anything I'd ever heard at any price.  It was not only wide, but so DEEP and holographic that it would stop you in your tracks.  

Amazing.  Sounded gorgeous.  A friend at the time who lived around the corner still had the first pair of Magnepans ever sold.  He bought them new.  They sounded AMAZING.  But again, large rooms, high ceilings.  12 feet, at least. 

I favor this environment for Magnepans and I always suggest this to those interested in Maggies.  

Regarding the sublimes, any other thoughts?  Do you feel they color the sound at all?  Are you satisfied with how they dial things in and tune your system?  Do you feel you're at an advantage sonically?  Cleaner?  Less distortion?  Or just different from passive, as opposed to "better." 

Oh, and another note -  the best setup I'd ever had that I described in my last post --- LAMP CORD.  Yep.  Plain old cheap copper wire.  I always get a kick out of that. I have decent cables now.  Wireworld oasis 8 and some audio quest, etc.  

So I definitely think wires and cables can make sonic differences.  But I always like to temper my desire for higher cables by reminding myself that the best sounding system I ever had was with cheap lamp cord type speaker wire.  HA.  I laugh just thinking about that now.  I used that wire from around 1995 to around 2015.  It really is interesting how that works.  Pretty cool, though.   Hope someone finds the stories helpful.  And thanks to Russ69.  I've been busy working, but absolutely need to pull my banana connectors out further and listen for just this.  I never used to push them all the way in, but at some point began doing so.  Thank you.  Very cool logo, by the way.  I've wanted to get a boat for a long time.  

@nevada_matt 

regarding amplification - I'm a pretty low-volume listener, these days.  But I wasn't always.  I also used to have my system on as I worked about the house.  I always loved the way Maggies sounded so LIVE from other rooms.  I used several amps over the years.  Definitely 800 watts per channel.  And more when I had a bridged setup.  My current setup is giving around 1000 watts per channel into the 3.5's.  

They are fine.  Very difficult to push them too hard.  But despite popular opinion, I'd always leave the fuses in.  They're there for a reason and I've blown many over the years.  Usually an error of my own like turning preamp off first like a dummy after too many glasses of wine or something.  But certainly if you're blasting your music for extended periods, this can blow fuses.  But that's what they're there for.  If you're using that kind of power, I'd suggest the 3.7i.  But those are not setup for bi-wire.  So I'd go for a used pair of 3.6's in excellent condition.  I see them pop up from time to time.   Great value for your dollar.  And the used prices are quite stable so you should get your money back fairly easily if you don't love them.  At those volumes, you could EASILY aggravate soon-to-be delaminated speakers.  So even speakers that sound great during audition with no buzzing, rattling or distortion, could develop issues after weeks of playing loud levels like you're describing.  I'd just be prepared for a possible refurbishing by Magnepan.  Which will still be well worth it, in my opinion.  I'm obviously biased to the Magnepan sound.  For the smaller Maggies, I'd say your amps' power is overkill for anything below the 1.7's 

The 1'7's would still benefit from the extra headroom, in my opinion.  I'm pretty sure there are reviewers out there who suggest that even the LRS benefit from loads of power like you're talking about.  

I haven't heard your amps in person, so I am just giving my general opinion based on power rating.  Whatever Maggies you choose, if you go that route, my suggestion is AT LEAST four feet from rear wall.  I had them six feet at least in my optimal setup.  They love the extra space. Once you go closer to the wall than that, I think other speakers sound better in a lot of ways.  

Good luck.