There are families of DD turntables, just as there are families of belt-drive and idler-drive types. You auditioned only one "brand": Technics. First of all, I find it hard to believe that you didn't hear substantial differences between the 1200G and the other two and between the Mk3-based Dobbins turntable and the Mk2 with no plinth. The 1200G uses a coreless motor, which makes it fundamentally different from its forebears. The Mk3 in any iteration should blow away the Mk2, let alone a Mk2 with no plinth. I easily heard big differences between Mk2 and Mk3 in similar slate plinths, in my system. However, it's possible that all 3 take the Technics approach to servo control, which is very tight. I don't like to think so, but perhaps you are "hearing" that tight control of platter speed that results. There are other DD's with coreless motors and "looser" servo feedback mechanisms, like the Kenwood and maybe the Victor TT101 (which would have to be re-plinthed or the plinth modified) that you might find more like your 301, but better. And there's also the Luxman PD444 and the Yamaha GT2000X. So, you have DD's with iron core motors vs coreless motors, DD's with heavy vs light platters, and DD's with varying tightness of the servo control mechanism. Each of these design choices makes a difference to SQ. Not to mention the effects of plinth, tonearm, cartridge. Generalizations are hazardous, because they make you stop thinking.
Loricraft Garrard 301 to Dobbins Sp10 Mk3 - What can I expect ?
Folks,
I have been using a nicely modded Loricraft Garrard 301 for the last couple of years. Found a good deal on a Steve Dobbins Sp10 Mk3 and pulled the trigger on it. It will be arriving in a week or so. I am curious what can I expect from this change ? The Sp10 Mk2 didnt cut it for me nor the new SL-1200G. Mk3 that too coming from Dobbins seems to be on a much higher plane. However I would love to hear from you guys if you have heard the Mk3 vs 301.
I have been using a nicely modded Loricraft Garrard 301 for the last couple of years. Found a good deal on a Steve Dobbins Sp10 Mk3 and pulled the trigger on it. It will be arriving in a week or so. I am curious what can I expect from this change ? The Sp10 Mk2 didnt cut it for me nor the new SL-1200G. Mk3 that too coming from Dobbins seems to be on a much higher plane. However I would love to hear from you guys if you have heard the Mk3 vs 301.