Lesson Learned


I've been an audiophile and music lover for over 30 years. It has taken me a very long time to get to the point where I'm totally satisfied with my system. I've made foolish statements declaring I will never upgrade/sell my current amplifier or preamplifier. Recently I succumb to four individuals telling me to sell my Jeff Rowland 625 S2 amplifier. Of the four, two were dealers(one dealer sold both amplifiers), one owned one of the amplifiers, and finally, my friend recommended the change. My friend all but guaranteed I was making a significant step forward. I was intrigued because both amplifiers were below 20K. So, I put my amplifier up for sale and decided to listen to their recommendations.
I auditioned the first amplifier at a retail store. Although the system was different than mine, I was familiar with a couple of the components. I listened for several hours and decided that amplifier wasn't for me. I listened to the second amplifier at my very good friend's house. All four of the aforementioned individuals recommended the second amplifier. My initial listening session showed a lot of promise. I was convinced that it indeed may be a step-up from my 625 S2 in some categories. In particular, the bass seemed more powerful. I was unsure about the midrange and highs, but I was interested in listening again. A couple days later I returned and listened with music that I was very familiar with. The second session had me confused. I told my friend the only way to really be sure about which one I preferred was with an home audition.
So, it was show time. I disconnected my Jeff Rowland 625 S2 and connected the mono-amplifiers. From the first note I was almost certain of the outcome. I began by playing Kirk Whalum's For You CD. Although the amplifier was broken in with several hundred hours on it, something just didn't sound correct. I decided to let the music play in the background for awhile prior to doing any serious listening. I played song after song. It's funny that this amplifier was praised for its outstanding midrange and bass, but the 625 S2's midrange was more detailed, had more air, and just had a more convincing "illusion" of live sound. The bass on the other amplifier had slightly louder bass, but it lacked the articulation and realism of the 625 S2's bass. Of course I'm keeping my Jeff Rowland 625 S2. The 625 S2 may not be everyone's preference, but I submit it's much better than I ever expected. More than any individual component, I believe my system has synergy. Having synergy will make it very hard to improve upon without spending a significant amount of money or going in a drastically different direction. 
I refused to name the other amplifiers, because it's about my journey and my lesson learned. I don't want my posting to turn into an argument about product "X" against product "Y". I sincerely hope my story will provide "food for thought" for anyone contemplating changing any component because someone else suggested to do so. Trust you own ears! No matter what anyone recommends, if your "ears" don't recommend it, trust your own ears! Finally, just because I preferred the 625 S2 in my system doesn't invalidate the recommendations. Audiophiles hear differently, have different preferences and expectations. In addition, it's more about the "system" than an individual component. This has truly reinforced that there are no absolutes in audio, only preferences.
ricred1

Showing 10 responses by ricred1

onhwy61,
I'm satisfied with my system, but I think out loud. I've had my Rowland components for almost two years. I will tinker with power cords and other tweaks. My speakers, music server, and Rowland components are here to stay for the foreseeable future. 

inna,
You said, "different amps may require different cables to sound their best." Yes Sir, you are correct, that's why I said my finding doesn't mean their recommendations are invalid. My conclusion just means that I prefer a different sound and/or the amplifier wasn't a good match for the rest of my system. 
david_ten,
"One aspect that we tend to overlook or not give enough weight to is our 'relationship' to the system and it's sound. Once connected, it can be difficult to walk away...yet there are others who like to 'date' a lot of equipment and have difficulty committing."
I would agree with that, but I've changed several things over the years. As a matter of fact I recently replaced my Bryston BDP2 music server with a Antipodes DS GT music server. From the very first note, "my jaw dropped"! I immediately sold my BDP2. So, if I hear something that I prefer more, I have no problem keeping it!
My other message is to hopefully get "us" to stop talking "at each other " and arguing about individual opinions. We want what we like to be the end all best and God forbid, someone prefers something else, they can't hear or they're crazy. We should be able to share our findings without being ridiculed. 

inna,

There are an infinite amount of combinations that we can come up with; how many cable manufactures are there?  My post wasn't about a component being good or bad or trying every conceivable combination in the world. My post is about taking every opinion with a grain of salt and letting your own ears decide. I know it's in the context of my system/room and that's part of my point. In another system/room the amplifier in question may be preferred over my 625 S2. I submit you limit the variables when a component is being evaluate. If not, how can you identify the sonic signature of the new component?
G.
You would be right to post: I TOLD YOU DON'T DO IT OR I TOLD YOU SO! I really appreciate all of your advice, but it's reassuring to hear something and let your own ears determine the outcome. I'm looking at a few options regarding power cords and the Rowland PSU. I just want to do a few tweaks. Thanks again!

I agree that we are limited to what we have access to. I'm lucky to have a very good friend that happens to be a dealer. That being said, he doesn't carry much of what I prefer, but it still gives me an opportunity to hear a lot more gear that most people.   
bigkidz,

I'm 100% positive the dealer was the only one of the four that actually heard the Jeff Rowland 625 S2. That shouldn't surprise anyone. I would guess that upwards of 75%, give or take a few percentage points, have never listened to the component that they condemn.  
Sometimes I feel like "we" are partly responsible for hyping the differences between components. As I mature in this hobby, I'm trying hard to identify differences without exaggerating them. After all, small improvements can equate to thousands of dollars.