I've had both except mine were the 1.2tl's. 2 different beasts to say the least.
The Polk's will have sound coming at you from everywhere in the room.Matthew Polk seemed to have done something to make these pyscho-acoustic in a way I hadn't heard before.On some recordings the sound would be behind my head.LOL Go figure. Lovely speaker with a bottom end on them that to this day I miss.I think Julien Hirsch had to measure them with some special equipment because they went so low. 16cycles with that sub radiator in that speaker.One of the best bottom ends I have ever heard.
The LaScala's would be my choice just for the fact that low wattage tube amps can be used in the future when you get serious about good amplification. Just my opinion but TUBES RULE!I did run the 1.2TL's though with a Golden Tube 300 B special Edition pair of monoblocks that by the switch in back could run them as a stereo pair or as monoblocks.Lovely sound but ran out of energy anything above 90dB SPL.
The LaScala's can take anything you throw at them but my brother in law has blown a tweeter using 500watt Heathkit monoblocks that he built.These speakers crave and need tube amplification though IMHO. They have a tendency to be bright and in your face otherwise.Really, trust me on this, get a nice tube integrated or a tube preamp/amp combo
and you will never look back.I don't mean to blunt or rude about your components so please take no offense but I've been doing this a lot of years and have some experience behind me in what I speak.
Whichever you choose best of luck.
Bill
The Polk's will have sound coming at you from everywhere in the room.Matthew Polk seemed to have done something to make these pyscho-acoustic in a way I hadn't heard before.On some recordings the sound would be behind my head.LOL Go figure. Lovely speaker with a bottom end on them that to this day I miss.I think Julien Hirsch had to measure them with some special equipment because they went so low. 16cycles with that sub radiator in that speaker.One of the best bottom ends I have ever heard.
The LaScala's would be my choice just for the fact that low wattage tube amps can be used in the future when you get serious about good amplification. Just my opinion but TUBES RULE!I did run the 1.2TL's though with a Golden Tube 300 B special Edition pair of monoblocks that by the switch in back could run them as a stereo pair or as monoblocks.Lovely sound but ran out of energy anything above 90dB SPL.
The LaScala's can take anything you throw at them but my brother in law has blown a tweeter using 500watt Heathkit monoblocks that he built.These speakers crave and need tube amplification though IMHO. They have a tendency to be bright and in your face otherwise.Really, trust me on this, get a nice tube integrated or a tube preamp/amp combo
and you will never look back.I don't mean to blunt or rude about your components so please take no offense but I've been doing this a lot of years and have some experience behind me in what I speak.
Whichever you choose best of luck.
Bill