Is There A Big Difference Between Subwoofers From Different Manufacturers

@phusis

May I remind you that this thread is about seeking differences between commercially build subwoofers. If you and @mijostyn wish to further portray the superiority of DIY designs then I suggest you start a new thread. Thank you for your consideration and understanding.

@mijostyn

I appreciate your insight and thanks for sharing. One can always contribute here objectively without showcasing their own prejudice or hatred for commercial builds.

If your purchase is not driven by your budget then there isn’t anything better than a pair of REL subs for 2 channel audio. The seamless integration with your main speakers and ease of setup with High Level Neutrik Speakon connection is godsend.

Good luck with anything else out there!

@ryder

When I mentioned budget in previous post, I was referencing to decisions driven by lower cost of subs compared to REL. The REL Serie S cost more but you also get the outstanding build quality and ample watts in return.

I own a pair of Carbon Limited and found them to be more than adequate in my 15’ D x 30’ W dedicated audio room. 

“Sorry for being harsh but this is the honest truth.”

@mijostyn Don’t we all have our own version of truth?

“Many people think DIY projects are second rate at best. It depends on the intelligence, experience and skill of the people involved.”

I am looking forward to your new set of subs, please do post good pictures before you hide them in the corner. My best to you!

“Rel subs are made as well as any commercial subwoofer. If you are comparing them with other subs on the market. They have two issues. I hate their method of integration and it is easy to get better subs if you build them yourself.”

@mijostyn It appears you have no direct experience with REL subs in your system and that’s quite ok. No disrespect to DIY’s community, but every DIY bloke thinks whatever ‘they’ can do, I can do it better. And please define better, what’s better or best to you or your fellow could easily be ‘good enough’ in someone else eyes. As humans we often tend to judge things based on our personal experiences and express opinions driven by our personal biases :-)

In my 30 years of audiophile journey, I have gotten my hands dirty in quite a few DIY projects. My experience have taught me to recognize and appreciate the differences between DIY and commercial grade builds.

@phusis

I see no sense in arguing with you further, nothing good is going to come out of it. Remember it was you who engaged me, it was you who felt the need to advocate and pitch the superiority of DIY designs. I couldn’t care less or more, cause I already expressed where I stand when it comes to commercial vs DIY subs. Next time you chose to engage someone here or another forum, learning first what they have posted and their beliefs will help you save time and embarrassment. It’s also called ‘knowing your audience’ which involves identifying the audience and adapting a speech to their interests, level of understanding, attitudes, and beliefs.

How far do you think I’m going to succeed by pitching an idea of DIY cables to a guy who has a full loom of Nordost Odin or Synergistic Research SRX?

My suggestion to start your own thread was based on your posts here and after reading your system bio. I knew exactly which camp you belong to and I respect your chosen path. It’s time that you open your mind to the fact that not everyone out there is inclined to build their own subs. Some of us are just happy with our choice of commercially build subs, irrespective of brand and price of admission.

@phusis 

Water under the bridge, let’s move on and be happy with our choices and the chosen path to enjoy music.