Is the Shuguang 5AR4 any good?


I am probably getting carried away here, as I now have three 5AR4s on hand (which includes the one installed in my power supply) and one in the mail and bids in on 3 more (which I highly doubt that I will be successful on), but I just got an offer on a couple of Shuguang and I like having spares and I kind of have a hard time resisting a bargain.

So does anyone have any experience with this particular brand of 5AR4?

immatthewj

Showing 9 responses by immatthewj

Thank you, @dekay !  That was an interesting read.  I did note that @rodman99999  had used a tall bottle, and I actually turned down an offer on a tube that the seller had listed as a "tall bottle" because I wasn't sure if there would be enough clearance to get it into position to insert the pins into the socket.

Anyway, thanks again!

 

@dekay   the one that is in the mail & on its way is a UK Amperex (which I was told here was probably made by Mullard) and one of the ones I have already received was sold as a Hitachi and I see on the base that it is labeled Matsushita.  The three I have bids on are Mullards and I believe that two of them are claiming to be NIB.  (AS I typed, I don't have high hopes for those, as I am not going to bid much higher, if even at all higher.)

Your thoughts are to leave the Shuguangs alone then.  Okay, I was just thinking that the price seemed okay and if they were as good or any better thyan the stock Sovtec, a couple of spares wouldn't hurt.

Okay, thanks. 

 

Okay, @jackd that’s probably the bottom line then--no point in getting them if they aren’t better than the stock Sovtec. I'll try to win one of those other auctions I bid on.

@jackd 

only one spot and it is true that I get carried away and overdue things.  I am leaving those Chinese tubes alone and I will see how it goes with the Mullards I have already bid on.

@dekay

thank you and I just shot you a reply thanking you for the advice. If you don’t get it, it is not because I am impolite when someone takes time to educate me, but for some reason it triggered a message warning me "Conversation added to Moderation Queue for Review by Support." Which I completely don’t understand, but so be it, and thank you again for adding to my education on NOS tubes.

And good deal on the coffee!  I can relate to that.  Maybe not on the coffee, but there are other things. . . .