Is a home theater even worth it or doable?


Please be honest with me. I'm a huge TV  movie fan as I'm sure many of you are, and in my youth I used to have a Denon setup, blu-ray, etc. I loved the experience. Fast forward 25 years and now I just stream my tv and movies off Netflix, HBO Max, and Hulu. We are doing a new addition where we have an open space concept. I see myself continuing to stream in the future, but would like a clean sound at least. I am treating myself to an 85" TV not sure the make model yet, but I want a big one. Does it make sense for me to even invest in something more then a sound bar given my streaming and open concept? If so, what type of setup should I consider or if I should prewire something up and where would that be? Thanks for your advice.
 

cody012

 

Not sure what your "open concept" space allows, but I can suggest a few things from my experience. We are fortunate to have a semi-dedicated but all-purpose family room that can be darkened with shades for projection TV. We use a 105" inch retractable screen and a Sony 4K Laser projector. The picture is great, but the decent sound system makes it even better. We use Apple TV > pre/processor > 5-channel surround amp > subwoofer. rear channel speakers are flush in the ceiling, basically invisible. Center channel is not visible but concealed in fabric-fronted cabinet below the screen.

Since you are apparently still working on your renovation, now is the time to install good sound equipment and discrete wiring. I also recommend soundproofing your room. We used RockWool brand insulation in all walls and ceiling.  This makes a nice difference and allows others not in the home theater to carry on without distraction.

Good luck with your project.

"Netflix, HBO Max, and Hulu. "

what about Apple TV, Showtime, Paramount, Prime, AMC, BritBox? Get your subscriptions in order first! :)

Most people (people not nerding out here on an audio forum) can enjoy a good home theater and most people spend more time watching TV and movies than anything else. Streaming a movie, or playing from a BluRay disc doesn't really matter, a decent system makes both enjoyable, and many people will never know the source unless you show them a disc or bore them with talk about streaming, and they still will tell you they sound the same. Focus more on the basics, like a good center channel as that is where most of the sound will come from for video. Get decent mains, and that is where the other important sound will come from for music and video both. Definitely pre-wire the room as much as possible if the walls are open, and keep in mind that most minor imperfections in sound stage from surround speaker placement can be adjusted from the surround processor. Get a decent processor/head unit that also allows you to play 2-channel stereo in some type of "pure direct" mode. Keep in mind that you may be the only one that is even concerned about having good sound in your circle of family or friends, and in my case not a damn one cares about the details of my system or spends time doing any critical listening.

Oh hell yes. However I won't bother going past 5.1 setup in my smaller setup 55" monitor.

I agree, a lot of streamed content sounds better when I switch the AVR to 2 channel.

Blu-Ray/DVD programming separates center channel info, that is just missing if you don't have center channel speakers.

rear, just loud enough that you are unaware until you turn them off. Black Hawk Down, they are key in many scenes.

Sub, I keep it low, but it kicks in for Jurassic Park.

I am primarily a two channel audio guy. But my partner is into movies.

 

We have what is probably the best sound bar (Sennheiser) in the bedroom with her 65” tv (she is disabled and more or less lives in there) and in our living room a 77” tv and a high end surround system… which we built incrementally over ten years… so we have had less expensive surround stuff.

 

There is a huge difference between a surround system with discrete speakers and a sound bar. The sound is instantly more involving. We go into the living room and watch movies together on the weekend.

In the end the quality of the sound is not quite as important as a music only system, because you are a bit distracted by the video… but quality really matters.

You can see my system under my ID. We have stand mounted speakers. With an open concept you will have to decide if you want to put some speakers in the wall / ceiling or just do basic 5.2.

I would stick with brands like NAD and Rotel as they are built to sound good not just have lots of functions. But in choosing every aspect all the principles of choosing audio apply. Separates are better, a big multichannel amp is much better… two subs better than one. Better speakers are better speakers.


When the depth charges go off in U-571 the whole house shakes. But even a modest system will sound enormously better than a sound bar.

 

I guess one way to look at it is our Sennheiser sound bar currently cost about $2.5K a $2.5K surround system would sound much… much better..

I probably differ from many, but I cannot bear the time, expense, and space of setting up a home theater system. I did a basic one, and while it’s fun, the friends I know with good soundbars (really good) with perhaps one sub are good enough for my needs. The sound is clear and accurate, there is spatialization, and there is minimal disruption to the room; this conserves space for a listening system. I’m planning on selling all my home theater stuff and economizing the space.

One further consideration for me -- for movies and TV, the story and dialogue are the main thing. I do not need to have a movie experience in my home. For really high technology movie experiences -- think, Dune -- I’m content to leave my house and actually go to a movie theater.