I should start with speakers. This I know. I’d like to establish a new system.


Returning to a hobby I abandoned two decades ago as life interfered with my personal desires. I’d like to slip back in with a decent package for streaming the likes of Tidal and Qobuz. I’ve relieved myself of all software (vinyl and CDs).

I am currently drifting between horns or BBC sound. Two different worlds, but each intrigue me. Considering Volti Audio with Cary SLI80 Integrated while also Harbeth 40.2 with something like a VTL MB185 Series III. Schizophrenic I know.

Dedicated Room 12’W x 30’L x varied vaulted 11’H.

i’d appreciate any discussion or feedback on my personal dilemma. Opportunities to sample these pairings are not in my immediate grasp, but I can consider travel (SE USA) to educate myself in the process. Budget $20k on used market. TIA

Ag insider logo xs@2xtoontrader

Showing 1 response by atmasphere

I should start with speakers. This I know.

@toontrader I’m not sure this is actually the best approach. But here are some tips.

The first thing you need to sort out is your budget, since if the speaker is inefficient you’ll need a lot of power and a powerful power amp that actually sounds like real music can be an expensive proposition.

So this points to the idea that perhaps a more efficient speaker would be a good move.

The other thing to keep in mind is that the lower the impedance of the speaker, the harder it is to drive, the more critical the speaker cables become and the more distortion the amp (regardless of technology) will make.

So again from a simply ’best sound’ point of view a speaker of higher efficiency and moderate impedance is a good idea. Distortion in the amplifier obscures detail and can make the system sound harsher.

Inefficient speakers have another problem known as ’thermal compression’. This is where the voice coil heats up due to the power being put through it; as it heats up it becomes less efficient and its harder to put current through it. So the speaker tends to compress, which is to say becomes less dynamic.

Your room is on the larger size of things so again efficiency is important.

Since you are already considering horns another advantage is that amps of less power often tend to sound better, especially if the amp is a tube amp.

Here’s something else to consider:

In many rooms you get a phenomena known as a standing wave. This is where the bass waveform is so long that it can bounce off the rear wall and coming forward, can cancel itself. No amount of room correction can fix this sort of thing because room correction depends on amplifier power and if its being canceled, even 1000 Watts won’t fix it. The solution for this is multiple subs asymmetrically placed so to break up the standing wave.

Audiokinesis makes a sub designed for this called the Swarm. Essentially they are placed against the wall in various spots and as long as they are not active above about 80 Hz will not attract the attention of the ear. This can work because at 80 Hz the waveform is 14 feet long, which means by the time your ear has sorted out what note is being played, the bass note has bounced all over the room and is entirely reverberant. So you can use a mono signal to drive all the subs.

The advantage of this is that the main speakers don’t really have the plumb the bottom octave. If they roll off at 40-50Hz you’ll have no problems blending them with the subs. This means there are a lot of smaller speakers that will be easy to place or you can use horn speakers that have horn loaded woofers (which in most cases, don’t go much below 60Hz).

Good Luck with the quest!