Apples or oranges. Of more like apples or apple pie.
An electronic recreation of a live event, no matter how advanced, can only be that: an electronic recreation.
Sure, when good electronics, one can think of a live event but it will never be the same.
The humanness of a live performance is a “human experience”. To see, hear and relate to a real person is very different no matter what the acoustics.
To interact with a “machine” can never compare to live.