What models are the amp/preamps? How old are they?
I would also agree with rixthetrick that there may be a dry joint or component failing in each (you need to be unlucky).
If you were talking about some sort of room treatment of a dubious source, you might attract more notice and help.
If I can think of anything further I’ll pop my head in and see how you are
doing. Good luck from me. 🇦🇺