I have DVD scaled amazingly well with my HTPC. I also have HD-VHS. The HD D-Theater tapes are so much better than DVD is and are likely going to be better than HD-DVD will be because of the tape's ability to hold more information than they will get on either the Red Laser or Blue Laser HD-DVD. While I like the DVD ability to chapter skip and it's smaller size, I will forgo that to get a better picture.
I find it amazing that when you have groups of people who will go to great lengths to get the most of their sound system seem so relunctant to watch tape. The studio masters are on tape. The simple fact is that picture quality is determined by resolution, encoding and compression. HD has superior resolution and tape has the least compression. It would take an encoding miracle for a 9 Mbit stream to give better results than the 28.2 Mbit stream from the D-Theater HD-VHS tapes.
And if HD-VHS gets as much support as LaserDisc got, I will be VERY happy. If something better comes along, great, but I won't wait for something that may or may not be better quality. Good thing I didn't wait to get Tivo until HD-Tivo came along. I would have missed out on TIVO for the last 2 years!
I find it amazing that when you have groups of people who will go to great lengths to get the most of their sound system seem so relunctant to watch tape. The studio masters are on tape. The simple fact is that picture quality is determined by resolution, encoding and compression. HD has superior resolution and tape has the least compression. It would take an encoding miracle for a 9 Mbit stream to give better results than the 28.2 Mbit stream from the D-Theater HD-VHS tapes.
And if HD-VHS gets as much support as LaserDisc got, I will be VERY happy. If something better comes along, great, but I won't wait for something that may or may not be better quality. Good thing I didn't wait to get Tivo until HD-Tivo came along. I would have missed out on TIVO for the last 2 years!