EMM Labs CDSD / DCC2 - Initial Listening Session


With only 48 hours of burn-in on these pieces, this review is hardly definitive- but here goes...

I think old Ed (Meitner) has hit the cover off the ball with this, his latest offering in CD/SACD playback equipment. The following comments are based on comparisons to my previous front-end: Meitnerized Philips SACD 1000, Meitner DAC6, Meitner Switchman II and apply to both SACD & CD playback.

The CDSD & DCC2 - compared to the previous Meitner rig---

-Much deeper soundstage, much more layered, as well, width about the same.
-Hall ambiance retrieval is vastly superior.
-Tonal and timbral qualities are unsurpassed in any digital gear I've experienced. Piano reproduction is absolutely stunningly good!! Acoustic guitar has the string interaction/wooden resonance of the real thing.
-There is a "Bloom" to instuments, even voice, that seems typically absent in digital playback. This quality is very "Analog" like.
-So far, I sense not even a suggestion of stridency or digital fatigue- It is just not there. This new gear is just plain musical. That word is overused- but there is no other word to better describe the overall experience. There is a natural seamlessness and natural bloom to the music, as a whole, which reminds me of a live performance within a live venue. All of the elements of that live experience seem reproduced faithfully by the CDSD & DCC2. This is no small feat. In quantitative terms I'd say the new gear is 25%-35% better, in every listening category (it is about the same in soudstage width), than the earlier 3 piece set-up I had.

As the new gear continues to burn-in there will certainly be changes and refinements, probably for the better, which I will try to keep track of. But so far- Ooh, La, La!!!

ASSOCIATED EQUIPMENT:
Kharma Midi Grand
Tenor 300 HP
Jena Labs Pathfinder
Shunyata Anaconda VX & VX Alpha
fbhifi
Robm321: It would seem prudent and most constructive to make purchase decisions AFTER a demo, not before. Also, carrying strong predispositions into a demo will generally skew the results of the demo to the side where one's predispositions lie. Approaching new audio products with an open-minded sense of discovery is essential to building a TRULY great system- one that a jury of your peers, in a blind test, would deem to be the superior sounding system.
I would have to agree with you FrankG. It sounds like the best redbook, SACD combo for that price range from what I am hearing ;) - My dealer will have a demo in soon. I can't wait to hear it. I'm not going to purchase but like to hear what all the hype is about.

Rob
Is everone who has the CDSD and DCC2 using the pre-amp that comes with the DCC2 or are their other stand alone pres that can do a better job?
Frankg is exactly right, I am a cheap bastard and there is NO way I would have spent this much if I felt it wasn't a good "value". The verdict is still out on the transport, however, it seems pretty clear to me that the DCC2 is hard to beat- if not impossible- in its price range and what it is capable of doing.
Robm231. With the DCC2 you're also getting a world class pre amp. Many pre amps in the $9000. to $10,000. range don't sound as good. Besides that you only need 1 set of i.c.'s and one less power cord. To me, that's a pretty good deal for sound at this level.
Gladstone: I didn't get into vinyl after hearing the Rockport Sirius III. If that wasn't enough to convince me, nothing is. :)
Robm321, May I ask what is the total ammount you have invested in your Vinyl playback system, including turntable, arm, cartridge, tonearm cable, phono stage, pre-amp and all associated interconnects and powercords?
Good review,

For the price I would expect nothing less than that quality sound. Another good sounding $10+ trasport and DAC combo.
Good review, Fbhifi. I, too, have the DCC2/CDSD combo, and my experience to this point mirrors yours. It is truly a benchmark in digital reproduction. Before I heard the EMM stuff, I was seriously considering going to vinyl; now I'm glad I didn't. Mind you, there are still fundamental differences between the two playback types, and many will stll prefer one or the other, but in MY mind the EMM gear renders the point moot.
no doubt on the sound!!!
but can he not design some better looking gear this emm stuff look's like it out of some late 70's sci fi flick. (which I guess has it place).
Sorry I just had to say something about how it looks like a FORD TRUCK but performs like a PORSCHE.
Some people will, however, prefer the DAC 6 separate and the Switchman. It's hard to put your finger on, but it may have a slightly richer presentation, less dry.
It would be a shame were the improvement to be in software as that was supposedly an easy update for EMM equipment. But maybe it is the built in preamp.
Nope, I did each in separate stages. For whatever reason, the DCC2 is the cat's meow.
Tbg: Since I switched out both the transport and the dac, at the same time, I don't know exactly where the improvemnent(s) lie. Possibly Tireguy could refer you to person he mentions in his post who, apparently, still has the Philips SACD 1000 running into the DCC2.
Great review, now I am even more eagerly awaiting my CDSD to show up! I have heard from another DAC6 owner that the DCC2 was a large improvement across the board, he could not believe it. This review vaguely reminds me of my initial DCC2 review, words that people have used to describe sound with in the past really comes to have new meaning with the Emm labs gear.

I have heard there is a significant improvement with the new transport so things that I felt were musical will be taken to a new height- I can hardly wait:^)
"...So far, I sense not even a suggestion of stridency or digital fatigue- It is just not there."

I like that.