2. analog
  3. 1238213441

Effective Arm Mass: What's the right way to guess?

I have a TT w/ arm where the manual says the appropriate cartridge weight is 2.4-12g. There is no mention of effective arm mass. Solving for a resonant frequency of something in the 8-10Hz area, and a cart weight of 12g, I can move around the compliance quite a bit as long as I also move the arm mass around as well:

at F=8, 12g of cart weight, 25g of effective arm mass = compliance of 10
or, 12g cart, 18g effect. arm mass gets me compliance at 13.
If I move F to 12, my 25g +12g gets me a compliance of 5 or so.

Is there a compliance number that manufacturers took for granted in these recommendations?

What does one do in this situation? Any thoughts?

The table in question is a Pioneer PL-90 which was brought out in the mid 80s. A friend would like to borrow it to see if he is interested in vinyl. I have been playing around with it but have not found what I consider to be the best match - I do not have many high compliance carts and I am wondering if that is the main problem.
t_bone
5 responses Add your response
t_bone OP
1,182 posts
 
Tfkaudio,
Thanks for that. That's not a bad idea. Will it tell me what the frequency is? I am not sure that I can tell the difference between 8 and 12 by myself.
tfkaudio
591 posts
 
The Hi-Fi news test record will work. Tracks 2 and 3 on side two have a frequency sweep from 20 to 5 Hz. The tonearm will start vibrating quite heavily at the resonant frequency.
t_bone OP
1,182 posts
 
Dertonarm, I think the formula you meant to write is the one I am using:

I use F=159 / sqrt[(M(t) + M(a)) x Compliance].
My problem is that I have two unknowns because the mfr does not give either F(r) with a given compliance or a make reference to a recommended cartridge, and as far as I know, it was not sold with one in the first place.

But the guidance for the 10-15 mm/N is helpful, and that's probably what I can look to change.
dertonarm
1,042 posts
 
Dear T_bone, if you have the resonance frequency with a given cartridge and know its compliance this formula will lead you to the effective mass:

F(r) = 1000 / 2 x P x ((M(t) + M(c)) x compliance)

F(r) = resonance frequency
P = Phi = 3,1482
M(t) = mass (effective) of tonearm
M(c)= mass (weight) of cartridge

Best regards.
dertonarm
1,042 posts
 
Dear T_bone, there is a formula to calculate the unknown effective mass of a given toneram, but it only works if you have the known effective mass of a reference tonearm and do know the resonance frequency of both tonearms with a given cartridge.

I do not have any other formula at hand.

With the Pioneer PL-90 and its tonearm you should get good results with cartridges having a compliance of 10 - 15 mm/N. Not lower. The Pioneer tonearm is not that heavy in effective moving mass.

Hope this is of any help.

Best regards.
Log in to respond
More to discover
80x80
TriangleART Master Reference $48000 retail
80x80
TriangleART Anubis Turntable
80x80
ZYX Ultimate Exceed Omega