Does old-fashioned necessarily mean out of date?


Having recently purchased an amplifier that I expect would not command the attention it might have a decade or so ago, it leads me to the following observation and question.

While technological innovation in the design and construction of audio equipment continues admirably unabated, I would assert that there are venerable products still being manufactured whose qualities seem to remain not only undiminished but unsurpassed regardless of the "cutting edge" products they are juxtaposed to.  I believe that one such product is the Ars-Sonum Filarmonia XP Universum.  It is meticulously--in fact, lovingly--constructed.  It utilizes high quality components assembled in an effective architecture to produce its modest but robust output of 28 wpc. Most importantly, the sound it produces, in conjunction with the right equipment, can only be described as glorious.  

So what I am wondering  is whether there are others who agree that the best way to go forward sometimes is to stay deliberately still.  And if so, to which pieces of equipment would this thinking apply.

Thanks.

mew2150

I appreciate the perspectives and insights that were shared by the respondents.  I would argue--in accord with some of the views that have been expressed--that  there has been an asymptotic approach to live sound.  The genius of audio designers and manufacturers has gotten us as close as can be to the "real thing."  To get any closer would entail attending a live performance. Reproduced sound can certainly be powerfully palpable, but it remains at best illusory.  Once it has hit that limit, the age of the equipment that produces that illusion becomes irrelevant.  

Your argument that there is a sonic limit is a baseless claim, it is not a universal truth.  It can be “your” personal preference that any incremental changes are not worth it “for you”.  

@mew2150

Seems you are on the outside looking in meaning you have not listened to current top gear. High-end audio the sonics are significantly much better and thus much more engaging than box store components. Trying to think box store to reality is all there is to high-end audio is wrong. Audio reproduction is not an exact thing, so there are many sonic flavors/presentations with different components. Only direct listening experience will you understand the differences.

The sonics are so much better and engaging- that’s why we pay a premium above box store prices. To truly understand, I suggest demoing for yourself, best a major audio show like AXPONA. It’s like visiting the beach the first time - it’s more than lots of sky, sand, water - words not enough to describe the experience.

There's any number of reasons or rationals in preferring older 

gear...or even the ones that have the qualities that one can simply afford 

and still allow the music to come through in the fashion desired.

Having to replace my hearing aids, the price of a decent level of integrated amplifier doesn't seem excessive, and has a major impact on what and how I

precive...

There's the risk of so many levels of tech between the source and the apprehension of the desired result that the discussion becomes moot...

Place your bets...;)

Hi, magh! Awhile ago, eh? *G*