Just like in real estate its location, location, location, in analog its set up, set up, set up. If its not set up correctly and yes small differences matter, the quality of the equipment will not shine through. I agree that you need the equipment and know how to do it yourself. Its part of the fun. If you don't have the patience or desire, best to stick with digital. Call me sceptical but no one else is going to do it as well as you, assuming that is you know what you're doing.
Does a turntable make a DRAMATIC difference?
I purchased some analog gear in the hopes of making my analog side (a Sutherland 20 20 phono preamplifier and a Hana ML cartridge) at least the equal of my digital side. Although it has markedly improved the sound of my records it has not equaled the SQ of my digital sources. I know my turntable ( a heavily modified Rega RP3 with two power supplies and many other internal tweaks) is the weakest link. My question is, will a new improved turntable make a MAJOR difference, or just incrementally improve the sound. Or do I have to spend major bucks to achieve what I want.