One of the topics that will never go away...
Hear an LP that is recorded/transferred on a nice setup, the file should sound identical to the LP.
Most of the Rock/Alt Rock from the 80/90's and beyond is digitally recorded. I would imagine the quality of the digital file/transfer(Digital to analog) for the "stamper" used pressing the LP would come in the question?
What sounds "better" or more "convincing" then, is the playback rig and the final subjective call from the ears?