11-16-09: Tvad
At this point in time in the world of high end audio, all recommendations and reviews have to be taken with a healthy dose of skepticism, IMO.
I considered that, and posted with the assumption we'd all be aware of that. But PSB has never been the audio press's golden boy in loudspeakers. That title gets passed around among Thiel, Vandersteen, Magnepan, Wilson, Magico, Usher, Sonus Faber, Martin Logan, etc. PSB is too mainstream, too conventional, too affordable.
Remember Siskel & Ebert? They seldom agreed, so when they did, chances are most people would like the film. I get the same feeling here. Anything that both Stereophile and TAS agree on so thoroughly and consistently (plus Soundstage and a host of other online pubs) *must* have something good going on. My personal experience bears that out. PSBs sound so good at their various price points you feel like they slipped you a ringer in the showroom.
And let's not forget, Stereophile is risking stirring up some high end speaker builders when they place a $5K mass-produced PSB right in there with about a dozen handbuilt $16K Class A Limited Extended LF picks.
So where it matters, picking the best at various price points, PSB rises to the top, from entry level up to the big dogs, and at rival publications.