Danny Richie on loudspeaker design.


128x128bdp24

Showing 6 responses by bdp24

@johnk: the OB/Dipole Sub CAN be confusing. The wiring of both the 2 or 3 woofers and the servo-feedback circuit has to be done correctly, or the sub won’t work properly. But the wiring diagram has been posted numerous times on the GR Research website and AudioCircle Forum. Plus, an owner can always call Danny for help---he’s a very nice guy.

When correctly assembled, the sub is like no other you’ve ever heard! Lean, no fat what-so-ever. Makes "normal" subs sound "plump". ;-)

@dz13: One thing Danny is criticized for IS resigning some of the loudspeakers sent him. His critics ask: what makes him (or us) think he knows more about designing than the engineers at, say, Klipsch?

Well, in his videos on various Klipsch models, Danny demonstrates exactly what he found to be "wrong" with them. He found the Klipsch crossovers caused the two drivers to be out of phase at the crossover frequency, causing a deep hole in the frequency response there. And when Klipsch introduced the Mk.2 versions of those same models, what had they changed? The crossovers, and in exactly the same way Danny had! So yes, Danny apparently DOES know more than the Klipsch designers. ;-)

On some speakers he finds no serious problems, and merely upgrades the garbage parts used in most loudspeaker crossovers (regardless of price): replacing electrolytic caps with film ones, carbon resistors with film, the terrible binding posts found on most speakers (which contain ferrous parts!) with his own Tube Connectors, etc.

He also addresses the ringing he sees in his spectral decay measurements (waterfall plots) he takes via compensation parts in the crossovers he designs, ringing left unaddressed by the loudspeaker’s designer (whether for financial or other reasons).

With some loudspeakers he finds the problems to be too serious to correct (often because of the drivers themselves), with others not economically justifiable. All of this is what he talks about in his many videos, a free source of valuable information whether you decide to modify your speakers or not. The info also makes you a more informed consumer, more aware of what to look (and listen) for in a loudspeaker you are considering buying.

And he charges no fee for the design work he puts into the loudspeakers sent him for evaluation, just the parts needed to implement his "fix" should the loudspeaker owner decide to move forward with the upgrade. I'm sure the owner pays shipping both ways, of course.

But remember gentle reader, GR Research offers it's products strictly as DIY kits, not fully assembled and finished products, though Richie has associates who will do the build if you are willing to pay.

@willywonka: Like me? ;-)

I hear ya. I have learned an awful lot from his videos though, and the OB/Dipole sub he and Brian Ding of Rythmik Audio collaborated on is really special.