dac recommendations for turntable listener?

I have immense experience in analog (several friends are also remastering engineers).  We use the same cartridge (mine is low output-I love this cartridge for my mono and stereo LPs, 31,100 of them).

I went through tube CD players and hated CD sound for decades.  The EAR Acute allowed my to get a semblance of analog sound.  I tried high priced DACs to no avail for 4 years.

The first DAC that permitted me to share in analog sound quality is the only Toppin g DAC we like, the D70s.  We haven't heard the latest ones.  

I opted for an SOTA DAC with pre-amp in the Lampizator Poseidon.  It is 50X more expensive than the Topping and only 30% to 50% better.  Even the Lampizator Baltic compares very favorably to analog.  I have 16,100 CDs.  

I splurged and purchased the Jay's Audio CDt3 Mk3 to go with the Topping, then the Poseidon.  My best friend purchased the lesser cost Shiit Urd transport.  Great choices like a great cartridge but the lasers should last 10,000-15,000 hours (my EAR Acute for 15 years of daily use-amazing).  

The PS Audio gear-open it up and looked at the components.  You'll know why they don't perform well.  

P.S. 2 out of 3 of the Topping units I mentioned sounded fantastic and 1 was sonically inferior.  For $350 to $500 current going price, it's a small investment.

Brinkmann Nyquist sounded the most like a turntable to me.

I have the Merason DAC 1 MK II and it has that rich midrange fullness that the OP is looking for.

It’s also reminiscent of a turntable.

I have regular access to hear the EAR Acute in use in the system it belongs to, as well as in Systems it is loaned into for demo' purposes.

I also have been present when it has been compared to a Audio Note Valve Based CDP, a Bespoke Built Valve Based DAC with a CDT, SS DAC's (Denafrips Venus II  and Bespoke Built Designs)

I have also been present over a period of time when Tube Rolling was carried out, where selected Tubes were Pairs that were perfect matches and measured improved over Factory Spec'.

Two Vintage Tube Types are now known to offer a little different to each other, but leave the stock Tubes as superseded, as a result of the leap forward discovered in sonic produced.

The Tube Rolled Acute has been compared to a Vinyl Source ( SP10 R > Glanz MH 1200s > Miyajima Cartridge > Bespoke Built Valve Input / Output Phon. Where a variety of SUT's and Head Amp's have been used, in a system using EAR Amp's and Quad TOTR ESL Speakers. 

As a digital to vinyl comparison where the end sound is being compared to have discover if a Digital Source has the capability to impress in a similar manner that a Vinyl  Source can.

The Acute scores as high a mark as I would be willing to give for being able to create such an impression.

In relation to the Laser Longevity, 15000 Hours vs a 1000ish hours for a Styli, with either enablers of a recording replay costing similar monies, leaves CDP's or CDT's with Longevity like the Acute seemingly a Great VFM Purchase.     

Look for a new or used Sonnet Morpheus coupled with a streamer/endpoint and loose the laptop. It's all you'll need to make music.

Audio Note comes to mind considering your tastes. You can also purchase one preassembled from kits at ANK site. All tubes, well known "musical" AD chip.

https://ankaudiokits.com/product-category/dac/

Denafrips makes excellent DACs, but they may not be to your taste. Highs are not harsh, but they ARE solid state, there is no 'warm' roll off.