CDs: FLAC v ALAC (v Digital Download)


I ripped most of my CDs years ago to iTunes in ALAC format. Considering redoing my favourites.

Is FLAC better to rip CDs to than ALAC?

Better to download at 16/44.1 from the likes of Qobuz rather than CDs?

jerrybj

Showing 2 responses by erik_squires

If there is any difference in playback quality it was claimed that it was in the different algorithms needed to decompress each. Either from:

 

  • Noise generated by the CPU during decompression
  • Different timings of decompression causing the buffer/clock circuits to behave differently

 

As a person who evaluates algorithms for a living, I’d say that IF this were true it would be very much something that would be implementation specific. There are several major variables at play. 

 I _think_ ALAC is a little better in terms of compression.  So long as your player supports both there is no reason to convert.