I think you might be hard pressed to beat your Yamaha for $1500 unless you buy used. I haven’t heard one of their vintage units in many years, but Yamahas tend to have a unique house sound, including their newest MOSFET amps. It’s not the most neutral, but presents string and piano notes with realistic "color." If you prefer it, prepare to be disappointed with many competitors. You might be able to find a used A-S1100 for $1500. Unlike most modern integrateds, its built-in phono stage (discrete design) is very good and extremely quiet.
Another great value is the Sony TA-A1ES. Even though it’s rated at something like 85 watts/CH, it’s not great for difficult loads or party volumes. However, if you listen at moderate volumes, they’re hard to beat for their used market price. They basically sound almost identical to the Parasound Halo - maybe just a hair better.
The Rogue CMII is also a nice amp. It had a very front-row presentation in my system, but fun nonetheless. Maybe a Magnum Mk1 can be found within your budget.
One thing worth mention: of the many integrateds I’ve owned/auditioned over the last few years, only Yamahas, a Cayin tube amp, and the aforementioned Sony were 100% free of audible transformer buzz. All others produced some level of buzz/hum through my speakers at idle, some louder than others.