2 way vs 3 way / Monitors vs. Floorstanding

Amen Nrchy. Prospective speaker buyers should pay attention to Nrchy's post. Well said and very appropriate here.

C123666 - well, whaddya know! I'm pretty much USDA-certified Clueless and didn't know anything about the Omega Grande 6 or 8's. I'll certainly keep an open mind on these things, 'cause I've never heard 'em (doh! if I'd never heard about 'em I certainly had never heard 'em), but please forgive me if I'me having a personal problem getting over the "dual-cone paper driver". I'm sure they've put some hard work into getting these things to do their stated 46- or 50-20K Hz - honest I do! It's just these darned youthful memories of cheap-o dual-cone car crud speakers, and now we're looking at $800-$1400 a pair. I'll bet they have nice cabinets...

Sorry - I really should keep an open mind. I'll do better next time.

hosehead....omega offers some fine speakers with 6" and 8" drivers that provide excellent bass for a moniter..these are not tiny speakers but the real thing..most expensive one is 1500, too. A nice pair can be had for 799 (Grande 6).

Be warned there is a long break in period for single driver speakers.

The comments on speaker and room matching are really important. Only problem is that there are also no givens there, mostly because there's so much overlap in what you can get in bookshelf and floor systems. You can do your research and all but in the end you have to try 'em out to know if they're too small, too big, or just right.

And from everything I'd ever heard & read, 2-way vs. 3-way is not a simple call - there are advantages & disadvantages to both. Crossovers are just one part of it - there are other compromises in 2-way systems (phase modulation, etc.) so in the end it's the overall design & execution quality of the whole system that matters (plus you'll still likely need a sub w/ a 2-way). There might be more than just marketing to why B&W, Paradigm, etc. do something more that 2-way toward the top of the line.

A 1-way (look ma! no crossover!) would be the most wunnerful if crossovers were the biggest/only issue. But only certain tiny-cube companies would do stuff like that???

A key that is often overlooked is your room & proper room matching. You want to consider the room your system will be placed in. Will it be there for a few months, or many years? Then you want to consider a speaker that isn't too much for the room or it will overload the room. Also, on the other side you don't want one that is too small and needs to be almost "over driven" and sound strained... keep the room size and proper matching in mind. Go from there, including the good advice above.

2 way...standmount or floor stander.

Merlin VSM-MM owner
Chris

Crossovers are subtractive, in every sense. They remove signal from the speaker. Good speakers will suffer less from this, but simplicity in the signal path is of prime importance.

Another issue that cannot be over stated is matching speaker size to room size. There are basic mathematical formulas that will tell you if there is enough room volume for the low frequencies to bloom, or if they will collapse. Big, floor standing speakers need a big room (if you're wondering if your room is big enough, it's not) to sound their best. Smaller speakers with less bass will sound better in a mid to small sized room. As a rule, smaller is safer, but you loose the cool factor.

Floor standing vs monitors is less of an issue. There are good full range monitors and there are good restricted frequency speakers that are floor standing.

It doesn't matter how good the gear is, or how good the speakers are, if they are too much/big for your room THEY WILL NOT WORK. Ego is a great motivator when it comes to buying speaker, but his sister prudence is much the wiser.

Don't forget to factor in subwoofer(s) if you like bass or have a large room.

the fewer the crossovers the better so go with a two way or a no crossover system. Book shelf speakers have the advantage of easier placement (ceiling, wall) assuming they are not too large/heavy. Having to acquire correct speaker stands runs up the cost as opposed to floor standing.

Bookshelf: easier to package and move!

floor standing model might make a bit better bass than comparable bookshelf speakers

You really cannot make an overall generalization about if one type (bookshelf vs floor standing) is "better" as there are plenty of examples in each category from a coupla hundred bucks to over a hundred large (for the floor standers anyway).

I'd give my left cojone for a Royal Device Diana bookshelf but they go for 15 large a pair; nice little speakers. I settled for Galante Rhapsody.